Gaming & Gambling
Take heart, Jocs!! Government of Andorra
Carlos Lalanda ·
I wish only to offer my modest support here to a just cause. In Andorra and concerning casinos, to be precise.
We have learnt today that the Government of Andorra, following a complex competitive tendering process for the award of a first casino authorisation, launched as a consequence of Andorra’s brand-new Gambling Law, has refused authorisation in the second stage of the procedure to the winner of the first.
Jocs SA had obtained the highest score of all the contenders; no one disputes this, not even the Government itself. However, it appears that the name of the proposed Casino (“Casino de los Valles”) belongs to another entity which managed to register it first because, in its application to the Trade Marks Registry, Jocs had made an error in a number on its application. And consequently it cannot use it for the time being ……… so what?……
Urgent legal assessment
It is true that clause 9.4.1 of the tender conditions (under “Documentation evidencing the tourist interest of the bid”) states that, in relation to the casino’s trading name, evidence must be provided of “the reservation of the name and the registration of the trade mark”. This is what Jocs did, and no one said anything, allowing it to proceed to the scoring stage.
The “requirement” concerning the premises’ trading name is so immaterial to the tender that, under “criterion 6” relating to the scoring scale in clause 9.4, the tourist interest of the project, no weight whatsoever is given to its bearing one name or another.
We do not know why that document was included in the Tender Conditions. We do not know, nor can we conceive, how the “identifying particulars of the name” could be assessed (scored, rated) in a tender, or how an application could be refused on this ground (it cannot have any significance other than that of a “particular”). Hypothetically (if the conditions so provided), a bidder submitting an indecorous, irreverent or denigrating name could indeed be excluded. For example: “CASINO PSOE”, “CASINO DEL PETIT CABRON (NAPOLEON, according to Perez Reverte)”, etc.
It would indeed be an essential requirement if the conditions had stipulated, for example, that the name must invariably include the word “ANDORRA”, and the project failed to incorporate it. Any deficiency would have been detected immediately.
If an establishment or undertaking cannot operate commercial premises under a particular name because someone else secured it first for whatever bureaucratic reasons (or even if it subsequently loses it following a third party’s challenge before the courts), it can always reach a contractual agreement for the holder to assign it.
And if not, it can simply change it and choose another.
Context and solution
This Andorra, which is striving and determined to turn the page and leave the status of “tax haven” far behind.
This Andorra, envied by some of its pro-independence Catalan neighbours for being the first country to impose Catalan as its sole official language.
Which had a king in the midst of the twentieth century who took it upon himself to declare war on Spain.
Whose Gambling Law not only permits casinos, but also includes the particular “audacity” of imposing a 10% tax on purchases of SELAE Lottery tickets, which in itself may already be regarded as an “act of war”.
Almost on the verge of fulfilling the idyllic and prophetic dream of Boris I of Andorra, of turning its valleys into the world’s foremost casino tourism destination (even before Las Vegas), albeit for now we are dealing with one single casino.
Now this Andorra is refusing to grant Jocs SA final authorisation for the project which had won the tender with the highest-scoring Project, because the winning casino has been left “without a name”.
Take heart, Jocs!!. Do not despair: there remains an appeal to the Co-Prince of Andorra who can resolve this setback: the Bishop of Urgel, with evident powers to rechristen it and give it a new name.
Carlos Lalanda
1 February 2019