Gaming & Gambling

THE TC SHOWS SELAE A (deferred) RED CARD. (TC Judgment 152/2014)

·

The Constitutional Court, in its judgment 152/2014 of 25 September, published yesterday, has shown SELAE something akin to a “red card” by declaring Additional Provision 40 of Law 39/2010, of 22 December, null and void. That provision enabled and laid the foundations for its creation. On closer examination, the consequent sending-off is deferred for one year (and it might therefore be more accurate to say that it was a “yellow card”).

The aforementioned Law, passed by the Spanish Parliament with a Socialist majority and concerning the State Budget for 2011, also adopted other measures which have been declared null and void, but those relevant to us were as follows:

. The Council of Ministers was instructed to establish SELAE (Sociedad Estatal Loterías y Apuestas del Estado) before 31 March 2011 and register it in the Commercial Register, simultaneously dissolving the corresponding public business entity Loterías y Apuestas del Estado (LAE), the last custodian of the historic State Monopoly on Lotteries created in 1784. It also laid the foundations for its incorporation, the contributions to its capital, and the orderly succession to its rights and obligations. The incorporation of the public limited company was formalised within the prescribed period, and its registration in the Commercial Register shortly thereafter.

. Rules were established for the transition of LAE's civil servants, who were given one year to opt for employment contracts governed by employment law, as most of them did, while the remainder were reassigned to other civil service posts.

. A particular supervisory regime was established for the new SELAE in respect of those Points of Sale still operating under concessions, although most of the holders of Points of Sale in the Commercial Network signed the so-called “commercial contract”, which was now undoubtedly such, being an agreement between business operators.

. The administrative powers of authorisation and control in gambling matters initially vested in LAE as a State-owned public undertaking were transferred to a body within the Ministry of Economy and Finance. Shortly afterwards, the precursor to the present Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) was created within the Ministry and took charge of those powers.

. Lastly, it was decreed that SELAE would assume payment of such financial allocations to ONCE as might be necessary in 2011 (in other words, cover any losses it might incur, as indeed happened).

All of the above was approved with the undisguised aim of attempting a stock market sale of up to 49% of SELAE's shares out of the 100% which the State was initially to own, which would have served to shore up the depleted public coffers. This transaction was planned for a time of financial pressure and, as is known, was subsequently aborted.

The challenge brought before the Constitutional Court

 The Popular Parliamentary Group in Congress, then in the minority, challenged this and other measures approved in the Law, resulting in some of them being declared null and void, for reasons that are clear in the light of constitutional case law. The Court has already had occasion to establish the limits of Budget Laws, which cannot include the enactment of provisions not closely related to the budget, since such cases require the passage of an Ordinary Law under which the measures can be debated more fully and with greater deliberation.

Such an important decision, even of historic significance, in abolishing a regime that had endured for centuries (direct operation by the State), undoubtedly seems to the TC too far-reaching to be slipped surreptitiously into a Budget Law, and it determines that it warrants a declaration of nullity.

And we find that it does so almost 4 years later (a delay to which the TC has accustomed us all too well), and moreover at a time when it is precisely the Popular Parliamentary Group that holds the majority in Parliament and, naturally, supports the current Government.

An “impossible” nullity?

The TC judgment itself notes a curious fact: SELAE had not been created by the challenged Budget Law, but by Article 14 of the earlier Royal Decree-Law 13/2010, of 3 December, (enacted 19 days earlier), in wording identical to that subsequently reproduced in Law 39/2010. This arises because, normally, each Royal Decree-Law, which by its nature derives its legitimacy from the urgency of the measures adopted, is ratified by Parliament and subsequently processed as an Ordinary Law, thereby remedying any possible grounds of nullity arising from the limitations inherent in Decree-Laws.

However, at least in this matter, the Government decided to process it through the Budget Law (which is what the challenged judgment prohibits), leaving unresolved whether Royal Decree-Law 13/2010, with identical wording, remains in force, a question which no one but the TC itself could definitively resolve.

If Article 14 of Royal Decree-Law 13/2010 remains in force, as the judgment under discussion seems tentatively to suggest, it would be absurd (or rather, wholly pointless) to declare Additional Provision 40 of Law 39/2010 null and void.

A “light” nullity

A declaration of nullity in a TC judgment normally entails the immediate removal of the provision from the legal order, taking with it all possible manifestations of the annulled provision, such as regulations, acts and any legal facts dependent upon it. This is what is meant by its effect (“ex tunc”, as though the annulled provision had never existed).

But in this case …………. how can the innumerable practical consequences arising from the application of the Law in its many aspects be disregarded? Let us recall that SELAE was incorporated and entered in the Commercial Register pursuant to the statutory mandate, and that, although the Spanish State itself retains 100% of the shares and certain privileges, such as the reservation of lottery operation, practically everything has changed since 2011: it has no civil servants, only employees governed by employment law; it has Directors and Executives governed by commercial laws and principles; it even has mandatory external auditors; its profits are subject to Corporation Tax; like any other private gambling operator holding gambling licences and subject to Law 13/2011, it is subject to DGOJ supervision; and even disputes with users concerning prizes, or with third parties such as the holders of Points of Sale, fall within the jurisdiction of the ordinary Civil Courts, without any procedural privileges whatsoever.

Under normal circumstances, the application of this “nullity” would be equivalent to a “legal catastrophe”, with unforeseeable consequences, since many of the legal acts completed over these 4 years would be liable to be declared null and void, including contracts with Points of Sale, which would probably revert to the former concession system; employees would have to revert to their civil servant status; a new basis would have to be found under the Gambling Law, the current system of “reservation” of Lotteries would have to be reviewed, together with countless unknown variables such as the uncertain fate of subsidies for Sport. LAE and its entire regime would be “resurrected” after almost 4 years of extinction.

However, undoubtedly aware of this impending “legal catastrophe”, the Constitutional Court adopts an unprecedented solution regarding the effect of the judgment. It limits the scope of the declaration of nullity, which is “deferred” for one year, until 25 September 2015, so that, where appropriate, …”the legislature may replace the provision declared null and void with another enacted by means of the appropriate legislative instrument”.

In other words, it declares it null and void, but “on a deferred basis” (the TC's literal expression, much used in legal circles). Or, to put it another way, it “does not annul it now”. At the very least, another identical Ordinary Law, or one with similar wording, will have to be enacted if the floor of the building, and the building itself, are to be prevented from collapsing.

What can be expected for SELAE over the coming year?

The foreseeable solution, albeit paradigmatic and striking, is for the Legislature, on the Government's initiative and with the support of the Partido Popular, whose Parliamentary Group challenged it, to enact a new provision within that period and with the same wording, since the alternative would result in something resembling chaos. Although this could also provide an opportunity to introduce certain outstanding amendments and reforms. SELAE is a company that “distributes luck”, according to its principal brand message, but it is nevertheless an entity beset by “bad luck”. The stagnation in sales of lottery products, probably due to the economic crisis, and the sharp decline in football pools products, caused mainly by competition from online betting offered by licensed third parties, are compounded by recent disagreements with the Sales Network and even the emergence of unexpected competitors, such as Catalonia's EAJA and the Grossa passive lottery, conceived in the image and likeness of the flagship Christmas Lottery Draw product. Nor should it be forgotten that the DGOJ itself has recently refused it new product lines, such as the marketing of fixed-odds betting through its Physical Sales Network.

It is therefore to be hoped that the judgment will amount to no more than a warning, and that the red card will not lead to a definitive sending-off, which brings us to one final reflection, repeated so often, on the usefulness of our Constitutional Court …. what purpose is served by declaring a provision from 2010 null and void almost 4 years later? And with its application “deferred”?

Madrid, 29 October 2014.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

carlos.lalanda@loyra.com

Article published in Elrecreativo.com and sectordeljuego.com

About the author

More publications