Gaming & Gambling
Resolution of the TEAC (Twelfth Division) of 23 March 2017
·
The Resolution of the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal (Twelfth Division) of 23 March 2017 declares that takings from gaming machines in hospitality establishments accruing to the proprietors of those establishments may be attached, and that the operating companies which own the machines and collect those takings are jointly and severally liable for compliance in respect of the share due to those proprietors. This Resolution is adopted under the concept of “unification of doctrine”, since the various Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunals had applied the criterion inconsistently, recalling for this purpose certain principles established in the case law of the Supreme Court when analysing the contractual relationships between these two parties collaborating in the operation, and declaring that these are not partnership agreements.
The fact is that the case law on which the Resolution is based (Supreme Court Judgments of 2 July 1987 and 4 February 1993) has not subsequently become settled, and, moreover, in certain particularly notable cases the opposite view is taken (as notably occurs in the case law applied in the Valencian Community, which has not been unified with that of the other jurisdictions). To this must be added the fact that ICAC resolutions consider that these may be quasi-partnership agreements, in which turnover is determined by the amount that each party receives from the machine takings at the very moment of their collection.
The Resolution nevertheless seeks to make operating companies liable for the share due to the proprietor of the establishment in tax collection proceedings, once they have been notified of the notice of attachment of receivables in respect of those proprietors’ tax debts, without the need for any further action by the Tax Administration.