Gaming & Gambling
Those Tempting Fees
·
At the beginning of 2019, the Minister of Finance criticised the State Budget inherited from her predecessor Montoro for containing a plague of “accounting devices” (later qualified as accounting “contrivances” or “tricks”) intended to divert attention, conceal defects or false promises, or forcibly meet the mandatory budgetary ratios.
We were already warning at the time that even she herself was not above such recipes, referring in particular to the amendments she sought to introduce in the 2019 Budget Bill in relation to the Administrative Fee (distinct from the Tax on Gambling Activities) collected from online gambling operators, including SELAE itself as a pool betting operator. The lapse of the Bill thwarted the attempt to redirect part of the revenue from this lucrative Fee to the Directorate-General for Gambling, within her own Ministry.
Well, in the State Budget for 2021, the measure is repeated almost verbatim and merits re-examination given its interest.
The Bill’s intention
The Budget Bill contains a new “earmarked allocation” item, through the introduction of new wording for Article 49.5. f) of the Gambling Law:
Twenty-second Final Provision:
“ f) 0.75 per thousand of gross operating revenue, of which 25% shall be earmarked for strengthening the material resources, instruments and investments necessary to undertake prevention, communication, awareness-raising, intervention and remediation initiatives that facilitate responsible gambling practices and mitigate the undesirable effects caused by unhealthy gambling activity, as well as the preparation of studies, reports and research work on the subject”.
It is accompanied by a further Thirteenth Additional Provision determining how to authorise this item, in addition to those ordinarily allocated to the DGOJ, now within the Ministry of Consumer Affairs.
The amount of this item cannot be quantified precisely, but these administrative fees amounted to €18.98 million in total in 2019, so that 25% would be equivalent to €4.74 million, to be allocated to those purposes through public procurement procedures and tendering processes of various kinds and values.
And so on each year, since this is not a measure with annual validity, but one amending the Gambling Law, if the 2021 Budget is ultimately approved with the proposed wording.
The proposed reuse of this revenue, which entails increasing the DGOJ’s spending capacity by almost 80%, nevertheless raises certain doubts which should be clarified through a brief analysis of the legal regime governing this “fee” and the consequences of the amendment.
The revenue and expenditure of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling
It must first be made clear that the expenditure generated by the operation of the Directorate-General for Gambling does not depend on the greater or lesser amount of tax revenue obtained from licensed gambling operators. From a financial and tax perspective, a Directorate-General within a Ministry does not generate “revenue” because it is not a collecting body, but it does generate expenditure, and that expenditure is what is budgeted each year under its programme.
In the 2021 Budget Bill, the DGOJ (now within the Ministry of Consumer Affairs) appears under Expenditure Programme 496M, with an allocation of €6 million (including staff costs, current expenditure and investments). And that is what it can “spend” to meet its budgeted needs. This is the case for all expenditure centres.
Revenue collected from gambling activities is generally not earmarked.
It should also be clarified that the amount of this expenditure allocated to the DGOJ bears no relation to the resources to be collected from the activities, companies and individuals subject to its administrative or policy action, which are vastly greater, as we shall see.
To clarify the scale of these financial resources, those collected by the State from gambling operators through one channel or another are included under various revenue headings in the Budget. In broad figures, they fall into several distinct groups:
- The revenue generated, as property income, by SELAE’s profit (for 2019, dividends paid to the State amounted to approximately €1,777 million).
- That generated by the Gambling Tax under Law 13/2011 on the regulation of gambling. This amounted to €145 million in 2019.
- That generated by administrative fees for services provided by the DGOJ itself. These are referred to in this commentary and, according to the DGOJ’s own report, amounted to 18.98 € M€ in 2019.
- That arising from fines imposed in gambling matters (€32.4 million in 2019).
- Finally, that generated by players’ personal income tax (IRPF); and, on the part of companies, the Tax on Economic Activities (IAE), Corporation Tax, VAT, etc., which are the ordinary taxes applicable to any activity. These cannot be quantified in advance.
- We do not include here the Gambling Levies on land-based gambling collected by the Autonomous Communities under Royal Decree-Law 16/1977, which augment their respective Budgets and together amounted to €1,337 million in 2019 (Anuario del Juego 2020 UC3M)
As in most neighbouring countries, under Spanish budgetary law, none of the projected budget revenue is assigned a specific purpose or destination unless a Law so provides (Article 27.3 of the General Budgetary Law), so that the funds arising from gambling resources and taxes are allocated for the most part to the general needs of the Budget (payment of pensions, civil servants, debt repayments, transfers for education, health, justice, and other general items such as defence, the bureaucratic machinery in general, etc.). In 2021, they will also exceptionally be allocated to all kinds of aid and compensation arising from the enormous economic crisis caused by the Covid 19 pandemic.
By way of exception, two “earmarked” revenue streams can be identified in the gambling sector.
In relation to the economic activities of the Gambling Sector, we can identify only two of the revenue items mentioned above that are earmarked (used to finance specific expenditure) because a statutory provision so provides; they are not free from technical controversy:
- – The Tax on Gambling Activities (excluding SELAE), on a “provisional” basis, provides for a distribution or remittance to the Autonomous Communities in which the players reside, which in turn augments their General Budgets (Article 48.11 of the Gambling Law (LJ)), involving questions of interpretation and tax technicalities which we shall not address here. (€99.10 million in 2019).
- The Tax on Gambling Activities collected from SELAE through its “sports pool betting” licence, which is allocated to various bodies specified by law (Third Additional Provision of the Gambling Law): the Provincial Councils, the Liga de Futbol Profesional, the Football Federation or the Higher Sports Council, in percentages that vary each year (€45.33 million in 2019). Nor shall we address the controversy surrounding that allocation.
In other words, all revenue arising from the Tax on Gambling Activities is “distributed in advance” in its entirety. All other resources, however, go to the general expenditure account. If the intention was to “earmark revenue”, the option could have been taken to distribute part of the penalties imposed by the DGOJ on offenders, which is the decision adopted by some regional legislators in this race to distribute public funds.
Thus, this budgetary revenue item which the amendment under discussion seeks to allocate to the Directorate-General would be the third on this short list of exceptions to the general principle and, consequently, must be placed under scrutiny.
The true nature of the DGOJ’s “administrative fees” under Article 49.5 f) of the Law
To add a few technical observations on this peculiar “fee” which it is now proposed to distribute, “administrative fees” are clearly defined as levies under Spanish tax law in Article 2.2 of the General Tax Law (LGT), with the following characteristics:
“a) Fees are levies whose chargeable event consists of the exclusive use or special enjoyment of public property, the provision of services or the performance of activities under public law which relate to, affect or benefit the person liable to pay the levy in a particular manner, where the services or activities are not voluntarily requested or received by those liable to pay the levy or are not provided or performed by the private sector.”
This definition is traditionally contrasted with that of taxes set out in paragraph c) of the same Article 2.2.
c) Taxes are levies imposed without consideration whose chargeable event consists of transactions, acts or facts demonstrating the taxpayer’s economic capacity.
The difference in nature is clear, and the concept is also clearly defined in the Law on Fees and Public Charges and in detailed case law and legal commentary, leaving no room for misleading confusion. Let us recall the case of the “Gambling Levy” itself: everyone knows, and the Courts have reiterated, that it is clearly a “Tax”, not a “Fee”.
When Article 49 of Law 13/2011 on Gambling detailed the concept and the various classes of fees payable for services provided by the National Gambling Commission (subsequently by the DGOJ), several fell within that category: those in paragraphs a) to e), corresponding to the tasks of granting general and individual licences, approving gambling platforms and technical systems, registration in Registers and inspections.
But the description of the fee in paragraph f) is completely different. The “fee” under discussion does not become payable because the Directorate-General for Gambling does anything in particular, but quite simply because the operating companies have greater or lesser “sales”.:. a genuine “tax”.
Something very similar, if not identical, occurred with the “fee” provided for in Article 71 of the Telecommunications Law of 1998, which had to be refunded to those who claimed it back after it was held to be void by the Courts and, like that fee, it is charged as a percentage of the operators’ gross revenue obtained from providing services to their customers, irrespective of the services provided by the Administration to the licensed companies from which it is collected.
In my view, this is a Fee and a revenue stream hanging by a thread, should any operator decide to challenge it. We have already stated that in 2019 this Fee amounted to €18.98 million, of which SELAE paid €6.9 million according to its Report, although I consider it an absurdity for SELAE to challenge this Fee against the State.
What if the Fee is subsequently annulled?
No one has so far decided to challenge this “Fee”. Companies are legally required to pay it, although technically it has every prospect of being found inapplicable.
What if a taxpayer decides to challenge it and the Court annuls it? This possibility ought not to worry the proponents of the legislative amendment. If a Court declares in the future that this fee is a disguised tax (and consequently annuls it and, hypothetically, it is refunded to taxpayers), ….. the allocations which the DGOJ will receive in 2021 and subsequent financial years under the new budgetary provision will most certainly already have been spent!.
Madrid, 10 November 2020.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Loyra Abogados.
www.loyra.com