Gaming & Gambling

The Directorate-General for Taxation and \»Expropriations\» of the Valencian Community

Carlos Lalanda ·

The processing of a new Gambling Law in the Valencian Community has been announced, and the text of the Preliminary Draft before me has been published on the Regional Ministry of Finance's website.

Among the many new features it contains, I shall focus on those of a tax nature, namely Title V (taxation of gambling),  which in some respects may be regarded as revolutionary if the intention is to retain its provisions through to the end.

On this point, the  Preliminary Draft opts to include all the statutory elements of the special taxation regime in the Gambling Law, whereas until now these were set out in separate Laws. This technique, which had hitherto been used only partially by Extremadura, turns out to be a “rehash” of rules encompassing both elements within State competence (taxable event and taxable person) and those within regional competence (all other tax elements). Albeit with the warning that this is a kind of “educational consolidation”, acknowledging that the former are identical to those laid down by the State and that there is no intention to encroach upon its powers.

Well then, beyond the educational function, either there are glaring errors in the text (which seems most likely), or we are facing a genuine perversion of the taxation of gambling, which may reach expropriatory levels. Let us take this in stages.

The Gambling Levy of 1966, that of 1977 and that of 2011.

As regards the Levy applied to betting, raffles, tombolas or random prize draws (derived from the “parent” Decree of 1966, the structure is maintained, while the rates for the first three are increased from the current 10% of winnings (or Win”) to 20%,  (that is, in percentage terms, by 100%).

As regards the Levy applied to games of luck, wagering or chance (Gambling Levy, B), the muddle of the “general” provisions and the “special rules” applicable to various games is inherited from the original Decree-Law of 1977,  but aggravated:

  • The General Provisions on “taxable event, accrual and enforceability, taxpayers and liable parties, taxable base and gross tax liability could have been dispensed with, because it is impossible to discern the activity or game to which they might apply, perhaps to “online” games proper, but this is a complete unknown.
  • The Special Rules concerning electronic bingo consist of defining the taxable base as winnings (“Win”). Consequently, the general rate of 25% applies, which is the current position.
  • Under the special rules concerning bingo “other than electronic bingo” (that is, “bingo”), the rate continues to apply to the total volume of stakes, as at present, and according to a progressive scale which, in the higher bands, may prove almost confiscatory, as at present. No account is even taken of the judgments of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (TSJ de la CV) indicating that the base cannot consist of the face value of the “cards purchased” (incidentally, at the counters of the Valencian Community's Directorate-General for Taxation (DGT) itself), but of those actually “sold to players”. In short, on the amounts staked.
  • The special rules relating to gambling casinos (table games) are, as framed, impossible to comply with, if they refer to the amounts “staked”, and not to \»Win\» or gambling winnings, as at present.
  • The special rules relating to amusement and gaming machines maintain the fixed amounts per machine, but increase them to €3,600 annually (type B machines); and to €5,180 annually (type C machines”).

In short, in addition to the technical uncertainties noted, we are facing tax increases (relative to today's resulting tax liabilities) of 100% (betting and raffles), 8.8% in the case of type “B” and “C” machines, and an undetermined percentage (casino tables).

And those that remain unchanged are the highest: electronic bingo remains at 25% (on winnings or “Win”); while ordinary bingo retains the percentage calculated on stakes, which in terms of “winnings or win” is between 40% and 55%, depending on the band.

In the case of casinos, and probably betting, the consequences will be devastating. To the point of reaching the situation described through a play on words by some authors in the early 1980s: an “impossible event” for some business operators to bear, which could give rise to the metaphorical image of “handing over the keys” of their businesses to the regional government immediately after the Law is passed and enters into force. And in the other cases, the impoverishment of the majority, a further marginalisation in relation to business sectors generally.

Let us recall a basic point here which is normally forgotten:   excise duties (tobacco, alcohol, hydrocarbons, etc.) are passed on to users in the price of products, and it is they who ultimately bear the increases and reductions; whereas the Gambling Levy (and its increases or decreases) is borne directly by business operators.

Let us therefore examine whether there is any confusion, or whether any remedy remains.

How the Taxation of Gambling Is Structured in Law

The taxation of gambling, in its various forms, comprises 3 distinct categories and is a State tax: that applicable to betting, raffles or random prize draws, whose “parent” Law dates from 1966, but whose current provisions were approved after the Spanish Constitution (CE); that applicable to games of luck, wagering or chance, whose “parent” Law dates from 1977, amended several times by post-constitutional laws; and that specifically applicable to State-level online gambling, dating from 2011.

Gradually over time, the first two have also been devolved to the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), both as regards their regulatory aspects (except the taxable event and taxable person) and their administration, inspection and collection (Organic Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities (LOFCA) and Laws on the Devolution of Taxes to the Autonomous Communities). In the third, the final proceeds are devolved (not under LOFCA, but provisionally under Law 13/2011). Lastly, the Autonomous Communities, including the Valencian Community, have enacted various implementing laws regulating the tax elements within their competence: taxable bases, accrual, tax amounts and exemptions, as well as administration and collection.

Furthermore, under LOFCA, the Valencian Community would have the power to approve surcharges, which it exercised in certain cases until it assumed full regulatory powers over rates and tax amounts, which in practice deprived that power of substance.

By comparison, the bases and amounts of the tax levy in force at central State level (currently applicable only to Ceuta and Melilla) are at present very similar to those now in force in the Valencian Community, in the principal sectors mentioned above: casinos, gaming machines and betting. In the case of bingo, however, the applicable rate is much lower: 20% of winnings or win, a measure adopted in the context of Law 11/2013, on measures to support entrepreneurs and stimulate growth and job creation.

Also by comparison, and generally speaking at present, both in many Autonomous Communities and in the Valencian Community, the structure of the tax is being redirected towards a taxable base of gambling “winnings” (in other terminology, Win or GGR). The only exception still remaining in some Autonomous Communities is bingo: and it is entirely consistent for this exception to disappear, because this makes it possible to see clearly the almost confiscatory level at which this game is currently taxed (from 20% to 65% of winnings, depending on the bands and Autonomous Communities). In the Preliminary Draft, as we have seen, it remains between 40% and 55%, depending on the band (except for the first band, up to €400,000 in sales, which is 3.22%). Also generally speaking, betting has been “normalised” at 10% in almost all Autonomous Communities.

What Is the Basis for the “Change” Sought by the Valencian Community?

We see an unpromising picture in terms of tax amounts and the tax burden on business operators, if we analyse it as a whole. Viewed by any external and impartial observer, an increase of this magnitude is almost revolutionary. As if corporation tax (IS) were increased from 25% to 50%, or personal income tax (IRPF) to 100% in its highest band (what would business operators and citizens generally say if the State Government adopted these measures?). Let us investigate the possible justifications for this revolutionary measure.

Are We Facing an “Ideological” Measure?

These measures were not in the programme for government of the party currently governing the Valencian Community. Nothing about eliminating certain private gambling sectors for any ethical reason, nor about applying a radical measure in the field of “responsible gambling”: “eliminating risk”.

The Explanatory Memorandum to the Preliminary Draft seeks to justify the generalised increase in rates in order to “adapt them to the current sociological reality ”a rhetorical expression bordering on irony, since the drive to raise revenue is not a “current sociological reality”, but something immemorial, which has always existed. As experts in tax history remind us, these confiscatory phenomena already arose in ancient Greece: “…..the tyrant encountered limits to his taxes, and the louder the citizens' cries grew, the more he persisted in demanding (Dionysius the Great of Syracuse), adding to the first \»levy\» a second, a third and a fourth, until, upon announcing the fifth, his henchmen informed him that the Syracusans were laughing and joking in the public squares. \»Now –he said– it is advisable to pause; for, if the citizens are laughing at us, it must be because they truly have nothing left. Otherwise they would continue to lament\».

(Einaudi, Mitos y Paradojas de la Justicia Tributaria).

Are We Facing a Revenue-Raising Measure?

It might perhaps be argued that the Valencian Community is in a phase of “revenue-raising emergency”.

Given the difficulties of Valencian finances, on the verge of intervention by the State, the results of excessive “nominal” taxation of gambling nevertheless appear to be disregarded: a reduction in “actual” revenue. This is what has happened in certain case studies: Andalusia, Asturias, etc. Conversely, any tax measure involving a “reduction” in tax amounts has always resulted in a “return to society”, through corresponding increases in prizes for players or investments benefiting third parties. This is indeed genuine “social revenue”.

Conclusions and Proposals

In view of the foregoing, there is little point in analysing the remainder of the Gambling Law under consideration if Title V is retained in the terms described.

It may be necessary and appropriate to invoke once again, if only as a matter of principle, the old “call for equalisation” of the taxation of the gambling sector: it would be better to impose a universal and equal “levy” or “tithe” on the winnings from all types of gambling, including online gambling: 10%.  The Preliminary Draft appears to seek the opposite: to bring the lowest into line with the excessively high, but by “levelling upwards”.

If nothing changes, and if I may be permitted this “licence” (since for now this licence pays no tax),  I propose an amendment: renaming the Regional Ministry's Directorate-General for Taxation and Gambling in a manner consistent with the foregoing: “Directorate-General for Taxation and Expropriations of the Valencian Community”.

Madrid, 1 August 2017.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

www.loyra.com.

More publications