Gaming & Gambling
Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Chamber, Fifth Section) of 7 July 2017
·
The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Chamber, Fifth Section) of 7 July 2017 upholds the penalty imposed on a betting operator for keeping an auxiliary betting machine installed in a hospitality establishment, with an upper screen broadcasting live and alternately the races and greyhounds on which bets are placed. The general prohibition on installing screens showing live broadcasts in hospitality establishments, laid down in the Betting Regulations of the Valencian Community, includes having them on the betting terminal itself, even under the original wording of the applicable provision (Article 39, paragraph 9). When this article was amended by Decree 33/2014 to expressly include the prohibition of these additional terminal monitors, this was not done to extend the prohibition, but to “clarify” its meaning. This interpretation rules out the alleged failure of the operator’s conduct to satisfy the statutory definition of the offence and the alleged absence of culpability, and confirms that the penalty imposed is lawful.