Gaming & Gambling

Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Fourth Section) of 21 December 2017

·


The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Valencian Community (Administrative Litigation Chamber, Fourth Section) of 21 December 2017 upholds the penalty imposed by the Valencian Government on the proprietor of hospitality premises, pursuant to the Valencian Gambling Law, consisting of a fine of 2,000 euros, but also, as an additional penalty, the revocation of the authorisation to install gaming machines on the premises.

The infringement consisted in the presence of SELAE lottery terminals installed on those premises, which were one of the so-called SELAE Mixed Points of Sale, and this was considered to constitute a very serious infringement because, under the aforementioned Law (Article 11.5), only games authorised by the Regional Ministry responsible for gambling may be operated on premises authorised for the installation of machines offering games of chance.

The Court rejects the argument that these terminals are, in fact, permitted because they involve games conducted at national level, which fall within the competence of the State rather than the Autonomous Community, interpreting the regional statutory provision as being clear on this matter and making no exception for these games.

The outcome of the contested decision, upheld in the judgment, is highly inconsistent with the interests at stake, whichever way one looks at it:

  • On the one hand, it operates against regional competence, since what ultimately happens is that it requires the removal of gaming machines authorised by the Autonomous Community in the lawful exercise of its powers, when the proprietor of the establishment decides to install others that do not fall within regional competence.
  • On the other hand, it regards this act as punishable, to the detriment of the proprietor of the premises, both through the fine imposed and, above all, by preventing the full exercise of the proprietor’s rights to operate the commercial premises, precisely because these are hospitality premises entitled to sell SELAE lotteries. The Court’s position therefore requires a “choice” between one line of business and the other, declaring them incompatible.
  • Lastly, it in fact indirectly “penalises” the operators of gaming machines installed on those premises to which the penalty applies, solely because the proprietor of the premises decides to install these terminals.

More publications