Gaming & Gambling

What the Hell Is Going on with Daily Fantasy Sports?

Patricia Lalanda ·

But what the hell is going on with Daily Fantasy Sports?… This has been the ubiquitous question at international conferences in recent days. In Spain, however, it is receiving little attention.

Setting the scene.

Daily Fantasy Sports (hereinafter “DFS”, in Spanish “Deportes de Fantasía Diarios”) are the newest variant of traditional Fantasy leagues. The concept of Fantasy Sports (“FS”) originated in 1950 in the US, and today 58.8 million people in that country actively play them, of whom 8.9 million play DFS[1]. In brief, and bearing in mind that there are various variants, FS are a type of game, generally played online, in which participants select a team and compete against other participants as though in a private league. These games are based on the statistics generated by real players in professional teams in any sport. Players pay an annual amount (entry fee) and are allocated a certain amount of virtual or real money with which to buy and sell players, creating their own team, which may differ from the one that exists in real life. Depending on your team's performance, you may be eligible for a prize at the end of the season. The sports on which these games can be played are not limited to football and basketball, but also include other sports of varying popularity, such as golf, mixed martial arts and eSports. Unlike traditional FS, DFS (“Daily”, DAILY) allow participants to create a new team every week, day or even half-day, and to select the same players as other participants. The ways in which prizes are paid differ considerably between one form of game and another. As regards prizes, most traditional FS, despite requiring greater involvement from the player before, during and after the season, do not normally offer a large prize (for example: $500 for winning, with a $50 entry fee). By contrast, in DFS, the amount with which a player can start betting is unlimited, $0 and even $1,000 on some websites, with access to prizes worth millions.

Black Friday 2 on the horizon?

In 2006, the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (“UIGEA”), one of the principal pieces of legislation to have shaped sports betting in that country, came into force in the US. It specifically prohibits US banks and credit card companies or payment providers from processing payments on behalf of and between operators of gambling websites. The UIGEA provides that the term betting does not apply to participation in fantasy or simulation sports game and that this therefore falls outside the scope of that legislation. Without going into the extremely poor legislative quality of the UIGEA, it seems clear that legislators were not thinking at the time of the DF model, since it did not yet exist and, as we have said, differs considerably from traditional FS models. Nevertheless, DFS operators cling to this exception to defend the legality of the game, as can be seen on some operators' websites. They insist that it is a game of skill. Indeed, Draft Kings CEO Jason Robins did not hesitate to utter the word “skill” at least 40 times during his presentation at a G2E conference in Las Vegas which I attended a couple of weeks ago. This is because, in many of the 50 US states, the concept of a game of chance does not apply, even where there is an element of chance, provided that the element of skill predominates. However, it appears that the DFS “easy ride” is beginning to face a serious threat. An industry in which, according to market research firm Eilers Research, DFS will generate revenues of €1.8 billion in 2020 does not go unnoticed by regulators, anti-money laundering authorities or Preet Bahara, the US Attorney for the Southern District of N.Y. who orchestrated the proceedings known as “Black Friday”, which brought the poker industry to its knees in 2011. Indeed, last week Bahara himself launched an investigation into DFS. He has been joined by other prosecutors from other states or areas… and the FBI. The main trigger came in early October, when a Draft Kings employee used inside information to form his own team at competing company Fanduel, enabling him to win $350,000. From that moment, the integrity of the game they offer was called into question.

In the middle of this October, DFS suffered their greatest setback to date, as the State of Nevada made it very clear through the Attorney General's Memorandum[2] that DFS cannot be offered in Nevada without a gambling licence. DFS operators now have several options: (1) applying for a gambling licence in the State of Nevada might seem the most obvious, but would contradict the “skill theory” they continue to maintain, which could harm them in other states that are much more lucrative in terms of population; (2) not applying for a licence and using advanced geolocation methods to block people located within the territory of the State of Nevada. We do not know at present what the outcome will be, but I would venture to say the first option, having already applied for and obtained a licence in the United Kingdom. In turn, this latest move by the DFS giant challenges the plans of Amaya Gaming Group, which, holding a gambling licence in that country, recently acquired a DFS operating company.

Meanwhile, in Spain…

As regards DFS, very little, at least for the time being. There is indeed a tradition of season-long fantasy leagues using virtual money and free-to-play games, such as Comunio or Liga Fantástica de Marca, but as regards DFS, there are interesting proposals from some start-ups with growth potential, even into LATAM, which, if they move quickly, may be able to secure a slice of the pie before Draft King, Fand Duel (and now YahooSports!) sweep all before them with their multimillion advertising investments.

Patricia Lalanda. 26 October 2015

Associate, Loyra Abogados

Article also published in  Azarplus.


[1] Data according to the Fantasy Sport Trade Association together with the company IPSOS.

[2] The Nevada Gaming Control Board and the Nevada Gaming Commission asked the Nevada Attorney General's Office to resolve the following question: “Are daily fantasy sports considered games of chance, betting and/or lotteries under Nevada gambling law and the Nevada Gaming Commission's regulations?” The answer was presented in a Memorandum which can be accessed here

More publications