Regulatory & Compliance
Who Pays the Price for the State of Alarm?
Carlos Lalanda ·
At 24:00 on 20 June, the official state of alarm came to an end after 98 days, and much has been said about the loss of human life and the difficulty of quantifying it, both territorially and overall. Also about the serious economic consequences of every kind, disputes over which are being brought before the overburdened Spanish courts, always slow and imprecise.
This litigation encompasses various aspects and jurisdictions. Thus, a significant number of criminal complaints have already been brought in relation to liability arising from healthcare negligence, against those managing the Healthcare Administration, (public or private), or against the owners of certain care homes for the elderly, and even against a Government Delegate or the Prime Minister. There is another area of potential confrontation and litigation as a result of more than a million administrative penalties having been proposed against individuals or businesses for failure to comply with restrictions on movement or the countless obligations imposed each day in the Official State Gazette (BOE).
The disputes arising from the resulting business crises may lead, and are leading, to commercial or employment litigation, and even insolvency proceedings, which the judges and courts of these respective jurisdictions will have to resolve. There are also the claims brought by consumers adversely affected by the cessation or defective provision of numerous services for which they had already paid. And so the list goes on.
In the very DNA of the Spanish Constitution, at the forefront of our legal system, there is an indelibly inscribed supreme principle, that of legal certainty (Article 9.3 of the Spanish Constitution (CE)), which embraces others that have been forged in the course of the development of modern States. The one I now wish to address is that of the liability of the State or its Administration for loss and damage.
State liability for loss and damage during the state of alarm.
Without entering into doctrinal considerations, the question remains open as to the extent to which the State must compensate individuals for the financial loss and damage caused by the Government's decision, endorsed in Parliament, to impose the state of alarm, and by the countless restrictive measures adopted under it.
It is not science fiction, but the BOE: Organic Law 4/1981, which governs the states of alarm, emergency and siege, literally provides:
“Article three.
“Two. Those who, as a consequence of the application of the acts and provisions adopted while these states are in force, suffer, directly, or in respect of their person, rights or property, loss or damage as a result of acts not attributable to them, shall be entitled to compensation in accordance with the provisions of the laws.”
There are countless cases in which the measures adopted have an obvious economic impact, for example:
-In a business that closed because the declaration of the state of alarm so ordered, is there an obligation to pay rent to the owner? Who must suffer the loss, the tenant or the landlord.
-Must the owner of a business that is closed because of the state of alarm pay an employee who is no longer working as a result? Who must suffer the loss, the employee or the employer?
And so we could continue describing a long chain of changes to obligations arising in this special situation dictated by the BOE. And manifested in financial losses and even damage. Is the State obliged to compensate for them?
There are no precedents in this regard. Nor are there any other precedents for the application of this Law and the state of alarm beyond Royal Decree 1673/2010, adopted on the occasion of the air traffic controllers' crisis. But that was something different.
If we try to find the solution in case law, we encounter an initial and general obstacle: the courts tend to accept that, where “general burdens” are imposed by statute or regulation, there is no obligation to compensate anyone, that each person must bear their own loss and resolve it as best they can.
Another obstacle lies in Law 40/2015, which currently sets out the foundations of the legislature's liability for loss and damage, making it very clear when and how payment of compensation may be sought directly (Article 32.3): only where the Law itself so provides, or where the damage arises from the application of a statutory provision declared unconstitutional or contrary to EU law.
In this obstacle course: is there any possibility of claiming through this route for the financial losses suffered during this exceptional period that we have endured? Let us analyse what has happened and the responses that the State itself has provided to the problem.
The “compensatory” legal measures adopted on account of the state of alarm.
Let us acknowledge that, during these months, in addition to the declaration of the state of alarm itself, numerous measures with the status of a Royal Decree-Law have been enacted in an attempt to alleviate the catastrophic economic situation brought about by the ordered suspension of economic activities, for example:
- All the extraordinary funds made available to employers, employees and the self-employed, and guarantees for businesses, all approved under Royal Decree-Law 8/2020. To date, it is estimated that, under the foregoing headings, the State has already paid out nearly EUR 50 billion towards this “compensation”.
- The so-called “Covid 19 Fund”, approved under Royal Decree-Law 22/2020, intended to alleviate the reduction in revenue collected by the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), amounting to EUR 16 billion, of which Tranche 4, amounting to EUR 5 billion, relates to the reduction in revenue from devolved taxes.
All these funds and special allocations could be interpreted as “compensatory measures”, charged to the State Budget, and this is not a matter of giving alms or practising Christian charity. These measures may be interpreted as constituting a form of compensation for the “liability for loss and damage” arising from the State's decision, which had to be adopted by the Government and was blessed in the seat of national sovereignty.
Thus, it appears that the State has already sought to remedy many of these calamities, but …… what about the loss or damage for which individuals have not yet been compensated? Could claims be brought for these through this route of liability for loss and damage?
With the Constitution and the Organic Law in hand, I am inclined to think so, but … to what extent and up to what amount?
Compensable losses in the gambling sector
Focusing on businesses in the gambling sector, there is no doubt that all land-based establishments fell within those subject to the mandatory “suspension” of activities under the first Decree 463/2020, from 14 March, and that this situation continued at least until the various territories entered the so-called “Phase III of the easing of restrictions”, as specified in Order SND/458/2020, of 30 May (Articles 41 and 42), with the devastating consequences of which we are all aware.
Thus, depending on when Phase III became applicable in the various territories, it would be advisable to gather the information required to calculate, on an individual basis, the actual financial losses suffered by the operators of these activities between the two dates (expenses, losses incurred, etc.). And to claim those which have not yet been borne by the State.
Under the heading of tax expenses, we have already analysed in other commentaries how, in respect of the special tax known as the Gambling Levy, in its form of fixed charges applicable to gaming machines, many CCAA have already reduced its amount or granted full or partial relief precisely for the periods in which inactivity was compulsory, since otherwise it would be clearly confiscatory. In the others, which have not done so, or have not done so sufficiently, I consider that these amounts could be claimed through the tax rectification procedure (before the tax authorities of the CCAA); or, failing that, also through the route of liability for loss and damage (of the State).
The Royal Decree-Law approving the “Covid 19 Fund” constitutes (indirect) compensation for the payment of devolved taxes, including the special taxes applicable to the various forms of gambling.
Royal Decree-Law 22/2020, approving the Covid 19 Fund for the CCAA, allocates a fund specifically intended to alleviate the reduction in tax revenue from State taxes devolved to the CCAA, including revenue from special gambling levies among gambling taxes, without distinguishing between fixed and proportional charges. The premise is that much of the revenue from devolved taxes forecast in the respective regional Budget Laws would not have been collected, and would now be restored to the CCAA through this route, but what about cases where they have already collected it or are about to do so? The logical and normal course would be to refund it to the taxpayers who had paid it, or to cease demanding it from those who have not.
It is nevertheless necessary to consider the scope of the statutory fund itself:
- On the one hand, the Royal Decree-Law itself excludes cases arising from the Tax on Gambling Activities (IAJ), applicable to online gambling, which is logical given that these activities have continued to operate during the state of alarm, albeit at a slower pace as an indirect consequence of other factors (the absence of sporting events, for example). Furthermore, these taxes are proportional to earnings.
- This exclusion also extends, because it is the same IAJ, to revenue collected from State pool betting. Here, those directly affected are the recipients of the indirect “historical earmarkings” of this budget item, who cease to receive funds because no revenue is collected: football bodies, Provincial Councils, etc. This is the unfortunate negative consequence of these earmarkings: when the spring stops flowing, there is no more water.
- Finally, fixed-charge gambling levies, applied to gaming machines, are a clear case to which this allocation from the Covid 19 Fund must apply: intended to make up for or replace the fair and necessary consequence of reducing them or granting relief, where this has not already been done, or refunding them where they have previously been collected. It is untenable for the State to compensate the CCAA for the absence of revenue while the Autonomous Community, for its part, continues to collect them. This is an even more compelling argument for seeking rectification of the Levy if the statutory reduction has not yet taken place. By what amount? At least the amount corresponding to the proportionate part of the charge for 98 days of the Levy.
Conclusion
By one route or another, the State should compensate individuals where financial loss has occurred as a consequence of the state of alarm imposed in response to the Covid 19 pandemic. It has already done so directly or indirectly in some cases.
In the remaining cases, it is advisable to assess the loss, to be calculated on an individual basis.
And not to rule out claiming compensation for it in a State governed by the rule of law such as ours.
Madrid, 14 July 2020.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Loyra Abogados