Gaming & Gambling

Why not Spain? …. On Brexit and the diaspora of gambling companies based in Gibraltar.

Carlos Lalanda, Teresa Valdelomar ·

1. Consequences of Brexit for online gambling operators domiciled in Gibraltar.

As the Brexit process matures, dates are already being put on the table on which, in legal terms, the United Kingdom and consequently Gibraltar will cease to be European territory[1], together with the consequences of every kind that this will entail, particularly the need to relocate all or part of the business operations established on the Rock by online gambling operators offering their services to European or non-European countries.

Some of these companies are already looking to relocate to other countries, such as Malta[2], for the simple reason that, under the various Gambling Laws of the Member States, the benefits of the freedom to provide services or the freedom of establishment, guaranteed by the European legal order, will apply only where the company is domiciled in European territory. This is all the more so in the case of online gambling companies if the majority of their potential customers are European.

In particular, the Spanish Law regulating online gambling, Law 13/2011, clearly provides for this in Article 13.1: a licence is granted only to nationals of the Community or EEA countries; (that is, companies with their tax domicile in those countries) _ Therefore, entities seeking to obtain and retain a licence under this Law must be domiciled in European territory or in EEA countries. And only licensed entities are permitted to offer online gambling to Spaniards. Once the United Kingdom leaves the EU, and if nothing changes, the ground for revocation of the licence provided for in Article 9.5 of that Law would automatically be triggered.

Although possible, it is also unlikely that an exception in this matter will be introduced during the negotiating process, or that Member States such as Spain will decide to amend their respective Gambling Laws……. Thus, where companies currently domiciled in Gibraltar intend to continue offering their services to Spaniards, they will have to relocate in their entirety, or relocate a demerged part of themselves, to any European territory ……

why not Spain?

  1. Spain as a location offering investment incentives, including for online gambling companies.

Following the various reforms to Corporation Tax, the tax incentives retained in Spanish Law essentially seek to create value in the field of Research and Development in Spain (research, development and innovation: I+D+i).

It is clear that the nominal Corporation Tax rate currently in force (25%) may not be among the most attractive in the surrounding countries. However, companies undertaking I+D+i which decide to transfer their tax domicile to our territory will, in addition to being eligible for other incentive measures (loans and grants), be able to reduce their effective tax rate significantly. As we explain in the third section, this tax optimisation is already very significant if they establish themselves in Ceuta, Melilla or the Canary Islands.

In the field of I+D+i, the current text of the Corporation Tax Law provides for two incentives: the reduction for the licensing of intangible assets (the so-called “patent box”) and the tax credit for investment in those I+D+i activities.

The first of these incentives aims to promote activities directed towards the creation of technical knowledge with an industrial or commercial application. Only 40% of the income arising from the licensing of the assets resulting from such activities must be included in the entity's taxable base. There is therefore an exemption for the remaining 60% of the income obtained. However, it is important to emphasise that computer programs are not assets capable of generating income qualifying for the reduction (although the principles or “underlying ideas” are: logic, algorithms, or programming techniques and languages).

The second incentive consists of a tax credit for investment in I+D+i activities during the tax period. Where the activities may be regarded as “I+D”, a tax credit of 25% applies to expenditure incurred during the financial year for this purpose. Where expenditure for the year exceeds the average expenditure for the two preceding financial years, the 25% tax credit applies to the average and 42% to the expenditure exceeding it. An additional 17% of the personnel costs of qualified researchers assigned exclusively to these activities may be added to this amount, together with a further 8% if investments have been made during the year in tangible and intangible fixed assets that are in operation (excluding immovable property). If the activities cannot be classified as I+D, the practical application of which is more restrictive, they may nevertheless qualify as Technological Innovation, which entails a not inconsiderable tax credit of 12% on the same expenditure incurred during the year. And there is more: if the entity cannot use the tax credit because its tax liability is insufficient (for example, because it is incurring losses arising from the commencement of its business), in addition to being able to use it in subsequent tax periods (once it becomes profitable), it is entitled to request payment of it from the tax authorities. This is, however, subject to a prior reduction of 20%.

And all these benefits are applicable, and are not excluded, in the case of entities operating in any of the gambling sectors: operators, technology providers, land-based gambling, online gambling, etc.

  1. Ceuta and Melilla in the Draft Budget for 2018, and of course the Canary Islands.

In considering a hypothetical relocation to Spain, we cannot omit a reference to the changes proposed in the State Budget Law for 2018 in relation to the taxation of online gambling, which encourage online gambling companies to establish themselves in Ceuta and Melilla (See the post recently published on www.loyra.com).

The Bill submitted to the Spanish Parliament provides for a substantial reduction in the tax rates applicable to all types of gambling to exactly half (generally, 10% of Win), for all companies with their tax domicile and “actual” headquarters in those Autonomous Cities, which, although not comparable to the almost total exemption regime in Gibraltar), do approach or improve upon others such as that of Malta.

It would be sufficient to relocate a few kilometres to either of those two Cities in European territory, which enjoy high standards of security and infrastructure development that the Spanish Government undoubtedly wishes to strengthen. Added to these are the significant tax incentives available to executives and employees generally.

A little further away, but with a privileged tax regime, are the Canary Islands, where the nominal Corporation Tax rate can be as low as 4%.

In short, significant investment incentives in Spain generally applicable to all business activities, now supplemented by the proposed tax incentives for online gambling businesses …. why not relocate to Ceuta or Melilla, a few nautical miles from Gibraltar?

Madrid, 6 April 2018.

Teresa Valdelomar

Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.

Loyra Abogados.

[1] On the Brexit timetable, see the link to the:article published by la Vanguardia on Brexit deadlines on 29 March

[2] On the relocation of some companies for this reason, see the link to the industry news item from Infoplay

More publications