Gaming & Gambling

Winning 250,000 Euros at Poker Legally and in Pyjamas

Carlos Lalanda ·

Last week, the press reported that a young man had won 250,000 euros in an online poker game from his home, having staked barely 50 euros and played for a few minutes against his two opponents. In Spain. A genuine milestone since online licences were introduced 3 years ago.

Let us dissect what happened, classify its elements in legal terms and briefly analyse its legality, as well as its subsequent consequences.

 Online poker, regulated for 4 years.

Until the Gambling Law of 2011, the commercial operation of poker in Spain was already authorised and lawful in virtually every casino in Spain. The Autonomous Communities have sovereign authority in this area and had very tentatively introduced certain more or less familiar variants. The case of Madrid, with the largest casino in Spain, is paradigmatic: it did not include poker in the Catalogue of Games until the 2002 reform.

After considerable toing and froing, Law 13/2011, which regulates gambling but above all online gambling, led to subsequent implementing regulations, including the Poker Regulations, which included two generic variants: “cash” poker, characterised by players placing actual “bets” in each hand of the game, with even no-limit games being possible; whereas in “tournament” poker, players pay “entry fees” to participate and compete at successive tables or in successive rounds, following which the winner is rewarded.

In “cash” poker, the prize pool or pot consists of the sum of the amounts staked by the participants in the various “hands” during the game, after deducting the operator’s commission; whereas in “tournament” `poker, the prize is the sum of the amounts initially paid by players as entry fees, less the commission set by the operator for  “using its rooms”. In other words, the prizes or pots are “pool-based” in nature, although we shall see later that there are exceptions.

A single-game poker “tournament” with 3 players.

At the end of 2014, the operator with a near-monopoly over this game in Spain applied for the legalisation of a “sub-variant” of poker called “Spin & Go”, which it classified as “tournament poker”, because the player’s participation was structured as an “entry fee” to play at the virtual tables, for an amount of between 1 and 10 euros. However, this was a very peculiar tournament,  because it provides for only one game, with 3 players, that is, a total contribution of 30 euros… how, then, can the prize exceed 30 euros, as the press report states?

The Resolution issued in the proceedings by the Directorate-General for Gambling in early 2015  gave the go-ahead to this sub-variant of “tournament poker”. It clarified that the game begins with a preliminary random draw which allows the ordinary prize pool to be increased to obtain an extraordinary prize with a multiplication factor of between 2 and 1,000.  Thus, according to this Resolution, once the participants at this table have been assembled, matched according to the amount of their “entry fee” (which must be the same, e.g. 10 euros), they are welcomed and a draw then takes place through a virtual mechanism with a random numerical outcome (in this case in the form of a roulette wheel or spinning reel). Most of the time, absolutely nothing will happen, that is, the pool will not be multiplied (meaning that the prize will be the same initial pool of 30 euros, less the amount charged for  “entry to the room”); but on some occasions the prize will be multiplied by between 2 and 1,000, by chance. In these cases, when the “randomly favoured” poker game begins, the participants will know the pool or pot for which they are playing against each other, with the first-placed player receiving the largest share and the others a smaller share. In cases where destiny and Lady Luck are more generous, a pool of 30,000 euros could be generated if we follow the Resolution to the letter.

It does not state the probabilities of this occurring;  although it is presumed that the poker operator is no fool, and that such draws are governed by software based on more or less complex mathematics under which, statistically and over time, the company never loses.

“Poker with a draw”, or “a draw with poker”?

But is “poker with a draw” lawful? This appears to follow from the Resolution authorising it, which refers to the Online Poker Regulations, Article 2.4 of which exceptionally permits that “on occasion, the gaming pool may consist of monetary amounts not equivalent to the total bets placed, or even of prizes in kind”; whereas Article 15 provides that “authorisation from the National Gambling Commission shall be required for the operator to offer prizes, whether monetary or in kind, other than those established in this article” . In other words, prizes exceeding the total amounts staked (“cash” poker) or the total entry fees (“tournament” poker) may exceptionally be authorised, without any regulatory maximum being prescribed for these pots.

That is to say, there is a regulatory provision allowing these extraordinary prizes. And this is an exception to the ordinary operation of poker prizes. And their authorisation appears to fall within the realm of administrative discretion, although “absolute discretion” is one of the techniques already repeatedly excluded by case law from administrative gambling law. Authorisations are not granted “just because”, but because their requirements are laid down in the rules and the applicant meets them.  For the “exceptional authorisation” to be granted, before anything else, it must be clear that the activity in question can be classified as a “game of poker” and, if so, within the “tournament poker” variant.

Thus, the legal classification of the game for which authorisation is sought becomes relevant, an intellectual exercise in which the entrepreneur’s expansive imagination often comes up against the greater or lesser degree of indeterminacy of any legal definition by which the Administration must abide when granting authorisation.

The Resolution essentially states that Spin & Go falls within the nature of the game of poker, and within that concept as a “poker tournament”, even though it is “accompanied” by a draw. Certainly, at some point a game of poker takes place, and within poker it is a “tournament” variant, albeit an atypical one with only 3 players and a single game. Furthermore, the Resolution emphasises that the draw takes place “before”, and not after, the game.

In short, “poker with a preliminary draw”.

However, it seems to me that the opposite can be argued: this Spin & Go may rather be perceived in the opposite way: as a “draw with poker”.  Is it the same thing?

It is true that the operator identifies and brings together at the same virtual table 3 players willing to play poker with an amount contributed as an “entry fee”, but first a draw takes place and determines the prize or pot to be shared among the players. Then, those “entered in the tournament” play for or divide the prize among themselves through a game of poker (just as they could divide it by tossing a virtual coin). What is important and decisive for the classification of the game is identifying the element of  “chance” in the event. The fundamental reason why players participate in this game is not the promise of a game of poker, but the outcome of the previously promised draw. Let us imagine that the process is the same, but with a four-player game of parchís or a two-player game of chess: would we be prepared, on that basis alone, to bring them within the Regulations on “Complementary Games”, which have the same rank and force as the Poker Regulations? Of course, those already include a maximum stake limit of 1 euro and a maximum multiplier of 40.

If we accept this alternative classification of a “draw with a game of poker”, we would be dealing with another form of gambling, subject to different rules on authorisation or prohibition, regulated elsewhere in the Gambling Law, not under the Poker Regulations.

The leap from “pooled”  to “banked” prizes

From either possible perspective (“a draw with poker” or “poker with a draw”), the authorising Resolution has permitted, because the Regulations for this game so provide (Art. 13.4 in fine), an arrangement hitherto rarely admitted in privately operated gambling: the possibility of “banking” prizes, by allowing, at least in some games, the prizes offered to exceed the value of the participation fees actually collected, thereby considerably increasing interest in the prize. It is true that several of the games offered in land-based casinos offer “banked” prizes (e.g. roulette), and it is then said that “breaking the bank” is theoretically possible, which does not normally happen because of the mathematical provisions inherent in the rules of the games. And these Regulations do not establish a limit on the value of the “maximum prize” that may be offered.

This applies to some extent to fixed-odds betting (land-based or online), where the operator guarantees the value of the prize in relation to the “odds” with its own assets rather than with the bets received; that is, it assumes a genuine “risk”, this time in each event on which bets are placed.

In lotteries, “banked” prizes are currently very rare worldwide, as they entail a genuine business risk greatly feared even by public operators (that insufficient tickets will be sold to cover them, and then… they “go bankrupt”), which is why only certain very notable lottery prizes close to home, such as the Gordo de Navidad, and others offered by SELAE or ONCE, are of this nature, sustainable only on the basis of the long tradition, trust and guarantee of the operator or guarantor (the State).

However, most prizes offered by all types of operators, public or private, are pooled and depend on the sum of the bets placed by participants or players. This is the case with bingo, all pool betting, and even most Lotto-type lotteries such as la Primitiva, Euromillones, etc., since they offer a large prize, but one that is “variable” according to the bets placed, by allocating a portion of the stakes, and no more,  to these special funds or “pots”.

Even “progressive” pots, such as the “jackpots” of the recently  regulated online gaming machines, are a clear example of pooled prizes.

It is clear that a historic milestone has been reached in Spain with this Spin & Go: the leap to large prizes banked by a private operator.

The variant is authorised by the DGOJ and is therefore “presumed lawful”

To recapitulate, and leaving aside the definitional issues referred to above, the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) classifies this game under the Gambling Law as a game of poker, and within that category as “tournament poker”, with a possible prize exceeding the sum of the entry fees.

In these cases, the Regulations require an “authorisation” from the National Gambling Commission (now from the DGOJ), although such an extraordinary authorisation is not subject to any “limit or requirement”. In its Resolution, the DGOJ interprets this as an almost discretionary power, such that, after assessing various circumstances and possibilities, it ultimately declares that “there is no compelling reason to refuse the authorisation sought”, having reasoned that it could only be refused on“justified grounds of public interest”, and after weighing various “conflicting interests”, including the possible impact on competition in the market. The interests it cites are the protection of public health and the protection of participants’ rights in general, determining, in short, that it does not affect the provisions of responsible gambling policies.

In short,  on the basis of this authorising Resolution, it can be said that this Spin & Go variant is authorised by the DGOJ and is presumed “lawful” unless and until otherwise determined.

It is another matter, and one of which we are unaware, whether this Resolution has been subject to any form of challenge in which its “legality” has been disputed.

It is also another matter, and we do not know the reason for it, why the very website on which the game is played offers an entry fee higher than that stated in the Resolution (€10 versus €50), and a higher multiplier than that authorised by the said Resolution (1,000 times versus 6,000 times). Minor details.

The “advertising” legality of “banked” prizes.

One final consideration concerning the advertising framework for these games and prizes. We have long pointed out that there is no legal restriction on advertising communications for online gambling activities beyond the ordinary restrictions inherent in advertising messages, regulated in other General Laws such as that on Audiovisual Media (truthfulness, non-discrimination, etc.).

In the absence of Regulations on the Advertising, Promotion and Sponsorship of Gambling, which the Law required, we can properly speak only of companies’ “self-imposed advertising restrictions”, breach of which is not penalised in any way by the Law, not even by revocation of gambling licences, as happens in other legal systems. No rule obliges the operator to provide information, for example, on the player’s chances of obtaining a banked prize.

Thus, as matters stand, advertising for Spin & Go is subject to the same restrictions as advertising for the Gordo de Navidad or the Grossa de Cataluña, with potential prizes far exceeding those normally offered in other games or channels. Almost none.

Each operator, within its “self-imposed restrictions”, set out more or less explicitly in Codes, does whatever its hired advertising creatives come up with. The campaigns are in their hands.

Although there are still apparently “legal” differences. And these leave SELAE at a disadvantage, for now. It is only fair to say that the right-hand column of the Spin & Go page explaining the potential prize of €250,000 also offers a promotion of 500 euros free to participate. “All players making their first deposit will receive a refund of 100% of that deposit, up to a maximum of €500. Get your refund”.

A similar promotion to play the Gordo de Navidad, , for example, would be “revolutionary”. It is even likely that some political party might include it in its manifesto in the chapter on policies for the management of public gambling.

Consequences for the fortunate winner of the poker game.

The player in the press report only had to switch on the computer in his room, connect to the operator’s website (where the aforementioned variant is easily accessible),  and instruct payment of the 50-euro tournament entry fee from his previously opened and funded gambling account. Perhaps this amount had been part of the “welcome bonus” provided free of charge by that operator.

After the preliminary draw stage, following which the 3 participants already knew that the prize pool was 300,000 euros, a short game took place between them in which our player had an “Ace” among his cards and had the “skill” to “call the hand” that gave him victory. It would have been regrettable if, with that “Ace”, he had declined to play that hand. A true poker “champion”. The “losers” took away €25,000 each.

It is hardly surprising that, as the press report indicates, the participant was nervous and his“whole body was shaking “. At home at midnight, it is not impossible to imagine that he was in his pyjamas.

Lastly, it should be noted that the Director-General for Gambling is quite right in his authorising Resolution to invoke the neutrality, in terms of health, of gambling variants such as this. News such as that discussed here helps many people to cope psychologically with these times of crisis.

Although it is not all good news for the lucky player. Someone will surely remind him that a prize of this nature obliges him to pay approximately 50% in personal income tax (IRPF), and that the tax authorities already have him in their databases because the operator and the DGOJ report it to them, and that there is no escaping; although he always has the option, on this account and to spite the tax authorities, of playing again and losing everything he has won within this same year, which would leave him exempt from paying any amount. This is almost what the winner proposes. Paradoxes of taxation and of the struggle against the excesses of  the Public Treasury. This truly is a game for poker champions.

Carlos Lalanda

Partner, Loyra Abogados

2 November, 2015

Article also published in elRecreativo

More publications