Gaming & Gambling

A wise decision in Catalonia

Carlos Lalanda ·

With the approval of Decree-Law 23/2020, of 9 June (D.O.G.C of 11 June), of Catalonia, troubling doubts affecting many gambling operators regarding their obligation to pay the special tax applicable to gambling machines authorised in this Autonomous Community are dispelled.

We had already warned in an earlier commentary <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">(See link) that the relief approved in Article 5 of the preceding Decree-Law 11/2020, processed urgently in response to the health crisis during the state of alarm, was highly confusing as regards the calculation of the tax liability, but also as regards when to submit the self-assessment and pay. Almost prophetically, we anticipated that, if the state of alarm were extended until 21 June (which ultimately happened exactly as envisaged), calculating and administering payment would prove all but impossible to understand. Indeed, several interpretations and circulars had recently come to light which were circulating among the tax offices of the Generalitat in an attempt to resolve this problem.

The position regarding fixed quarterly tax liabilities on gambling machines is therefore now definitively clarified in the new Decree-Law:

  • The first-quarter tax liability remains unchanged (at €1,004 for ordinary type \»B\» gaming machines) and the deadline for payment expires on 7 July next.
  • The second-quarter tax liability is subject to 100% relief (becoming \»0\» for all machines), and consequently only the \»0\» self-assessment will be submitted, between 1 and 20 September.
  • The third-quarter tax liability is subject to 10% relief  (becoming €903.60 for type \»B\» gaming machines), and the period for submission and payment is likewise from 1 to 20 September.

Furthermore, in the case of the special tax on bingo, with a tax rate proportional to the value of the cards played, it is provided that, for cards supplied to businesses in February, March and April, the payment period will be between 1 and 15 July next.

Lastly, in the case of the levy applicable to casino table games, proportional in this instance to gaming revenue, the payment corresponding to the first-quarter tax base will be self-assessed between 1 and 20 July.

We believe that this definitively clarifies and establishes, beyond any doubt, the liabilities and payment deadlines for these special taxes.

Payment

Now comes the most difficult part, meeting the payment obligations and paying all the tax debts, against a backdrop of business uncertainty and bleak  business prospects over the coming months, when many gambling premises for the various games are not even open yet, and it is not known how customers will react under the \»new normal\».

Operators still have a number of tax \»cards to play\» in this regard: the possibility of applying for individual payment deferrals or instalment arrangements for their respective debts; and, on the other hand, as regards future debts arising from the fixed levy on machines, the possibility of applying for the \»temporary suspension of authorisations\», (before 1 July) albeit accepting that in Catalonia these may extend only to a maximum percentage of the total stock  in operation.

The \»wise\» decision adopted by the Catalan Parliament may be met with another \»wise\» business decision, always to be expected of the ancient and civilised peoples of the Mediterranean.  One of the oldest known reactions to taxation is recounted from the time of Cípselo of Corinth: that of the Greek people in response to repeated tax impositions by tyrants. According to the texts, livestock farmers who were subjected to successive levies on the same head of livestock, and were unable to bear them, preferred to offer their herds as sacrifices to the gods, burning them in the public square, with the resulting tax exemption. (\»Mitos y paradojas de la Justicia Tributaria\», L.Einaudi\») Sometimes history repeats itself.

From Madrid, 11 June 2020

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Loyra Abogados

More publications