Gaming & Gambling
Alphabet soup. Clarifications on eSports, Dfs and Virtual Sports.
Carlos Lalanda ·
The acronyms “eS”, “DFs” and “Vs” are constantly used to abbreviate the English terms “E-sports”, “Daily Fantasy Sports” and “Virtual Sports”. What they all have in common is that they are entertainment activities offered through PCs, mobile phones, the internet or gaming machines using advanced digital technology. Let us pause briefly and, amid the confusion of this “alphabet soup”, clarify some key points concerning their actual meaning, their conceptual differences and, of interest to us here, their differing treatment under gambling law.
Their relationship with betting and gambling
For our part, we have already attempted to provide an explanation of how betting on Fantasy Sports fits within gambling legislation (see, for example, the article by Patricia Lalanda, “What on earth is happening with Fantasy Sports?” November 2015).
Another effort along these lines is being undertaken by the UK Gambling Commission, which opened a discussion paper on “Virtual currencies, eSports and social gaming”, in August 2016, and their implications for gambling and betting law in the United Kingdom.
Also of considerable interest is the recent French legislation contained in Law 2016-1321 <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">(“for a Digital Republic”, 7 October 2016), which establishes the limits within which video game competitions (eSports) are not, in themselves, considered gambling.
In our country, there is no known legal or official position on these phenomena, although some opinions on the matter have been expressed in personal interviews with members of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) and at gambling conferences.
Lastly, some regional Regulations have tentatively included references to them, without further detail. The analysis to be undertaken is therefore prospective and case-specific and, for the purposes of this article, necessarily brief.
Are these games of chance?
Do players play or bet?
Are they genuinely “sports”?
Spanish terms and possible definitions
ESports (Literal translation: “Electronic sports”). We should favour another, much more descriptive expression: “Video game tournaments and competitions”. This provides some guidance, since electronic technology enables players to compete against one another using devices in different locations and, more importantly, enables teams of players to compete against one another. Hence the large-scale leagues played on the most popular video games, and the audiences who watch these events in large venues or through personal devices
E.g.: League of Legends, Dota 2, Counter Strike, FIFA
The relevance to gambling law begins with the bets that spectators may place on the results of these video game competitions.
Daily Fantasy Sports (Literal translation: “Daily fantasy sports”). In this case, it is more difficult to establish a descriptive colloquial term, something along the lines of “daily electronic betting pools on certain real sporting occurrences”. This normally involves predicting which players will be best placed in actual leagues or competitions (football, basketball, etc.) on a particular day, and forming an “ideal team” through advance contributions, with the combinations in the “pool” winning or losing.
E.g.: Fanduel, Draftkings
The relevance to gambling law arises as soon as the contributions to form teams are “real”, that is, made with money, in which case they constitute bets, and the prizes have an ascertainable value.
Virtual Sports (Literal translation: “Virtual sports”). A more explanatory term might be “simulations of competitive games, usually sporting ones “. In this case, which is entirely different from the preceding ones, the game takes place through “virtual players or teams” controlled by software, which compete against one another and in which the user intervenes or interacts through certain actions and even bets on them.
E.g.: Skybet, Inspired, Golden Race.
The relevance to gambling law begins when the user of the virtual game not only “plays” (in the sense of paying an amount for a period of playing time, for example), but also bets on the virtual event and ultimately wins or loses the game, and consequently wins the prize or loses the bet.
Whether or not they are sports, they are all high-technology entertainment or games
The common basis of all those analysed is that they operate through high-technology electronic devices, whether PCs, tablets or mobile phones connected to the internet, or even terminals in public premises. As we have seen, these are entirely different phenomena, which are relevant to gambling law only when they meet certain requirements that would necessarily bring them within one of the concepts described by the rules applicable to this sector.
Hence the importance of conceptualising and defining certain legal benchmarks against which they can be assessed in advance to establish their correct legal classification, since the legal regime applicable to them will depend on this.
In both the United Kingdom and France, we have seen efforts to accommodate them within the law, as is also the case in the USA, where a genuine interest has arisen in defining these phenomena in abstract terms in an attempt to facilitate a solution in each actual case and, ultimately, to decide when elements of gambling are present in connection with them and they are therefore subject to the intervention appropriate in such cases. A task which, as matters stand today, with Spanish legislation in hand, is a task of titanic proportions.
If all those mentioned (eSports, Daily Fantasy Sports and Virtual Sports) have anything in common, it is that they are games or forms of entertainment with a strong technological component, which perform tasks that were impossible until recently, such as reproducing movements, figures and settings from the real world with great clarity and complexity (eSports and Virtual Sports), but also the ability to interconnect thousands or millions of users in real time as players or mere spectators, who in turn have the ability to interact with one another (eSports or Fantasy Sports).
The first caveat, applicable to any legislation, is as follows: unless certain requirements which we shall examine are met, these are merely games or forms of entertainment, and will therefore not fall within the ambit of gambling law.
The question of whether these are sporting phenomena or “sports” is a discussion that may be the subject of a separate article, and does not properly belong to gambling law. Suffice it to say for now, paradoxically, that if sports are characterised as a “physical activity”, none of the three activities could be classified as such ……… despite their names, and according to the definition in the Dictionary of the R.A.E.
Requirements for their inclusion within gambling and betting law.
The activities mentioned cannot, a priori, be regarded as types of betting or gambling, and all of them may be practised outside the scope of our subject matter.
They are entertainment activities which have been excluded from gambling Laws and Regulations, or even removed from them when they were still regulated. This is the case of the so-called “type “A” machines” in Spain, which, after a long period within the interventionist regulations governing gaming machines, were excluded from such intervention when the EU finally decided to define those activities which could not be treated as gambling, in the Directive on the Freedom to Provide Services: “…. Those gambling activities which do (not) involve wagering a stake with monetary value, including lotteries and betting”.
We can summarise the characteristics necessary to bring an activity within gambling, and thus subject it to the limitations and restrictions of this economic sector:
- Where some form of bet is entered into, which, under our Civil Code, exists when an amount of money is risked on a game or an event whose outcome is uncertain for the player placing the bet. Starting from this first requirement, it is important to distinguish whether the outcome of the event is external to the organiser (in which case we have a betting contract. Article 1799 of the Civil Code (CC)); or whether the outcome of the game or competition is determined by the player undertaking certain activity, under the control of the organiser’s gaming software (in which case we have a gaming contract. Article 1798 CC). This distinction would essentially correspond to that established in our age-old Civil Code. In the first category, we would include bets on eSports and DFs; and in the second, Vs, where the user risks money on them. In the case of the French Law passed a few days ago, no betting takes place where, in video game competitions, the sums paid as entry fees are equivalent to the prizes.
- Another requirement is that a prize be established as a result of the winning bet or the gaming programme, whether the prize is in cash or of any other kind. This analysis is the focus of the UK Gambling Commission, which includes in its Discussion the role and importance of “virtual currencies” and, ultimately, the case of so-called “social games” in their various forms. In the case of DFs, the prize is proportional to the betting pool, in which case we have “pool betting”; in the case of Vs, the prize is determined in the programme of the machine or system on which the game takes place. In the case of bets on eSports, the prize is normally established by reference to the “odds” set by the operator.
As is apparent from the foregoing, the lines drawn by the Civil Code or by the Law on the Regulation of Gambling assist us in the task of classification. Under the Gambling Law, the determining requirements for its application are the bet and the prize, irrespective of the skill or dexterity of players and bettors; furthermore, activities which constitute mere entertainment for players, without the possibility of a prize with an ascertainable economic value, are excluded (Articles 2 and 3)
Having analysed the foregoing, and in general terms, the phenomena mentioned above may be classified as follows under the Spanish legal system:
- (Betting on) eSports: If odds are offered on the events, this constitutes FIXED-ODDS BETTING.
- Daily Fantasy Sports: If a prize is provided for in proportion to the betting pool on an event, this constitutes POOL BETTING.
- Virtual Sports. If they offer the possibility of a prize (and not merely playing time), this constitutes GAMBLING THROUGH GAMING MACHINES, DEVICES OR TERMINALS.
In the cases referred to, the applicable gambling regime will be that determined, respectively, by the rules on Fixed-Odds Betting, Pool Betting or Gaming “Machines”, with all the consequences that entails.
Whether or not they are “sports” has no bearing on the foregoing, although in some regulations this classification is a further distinguishing factor in determining the application of one set of gambling law rules or another.
Carlos Lalanda Fernandez.
Madrid, 10 October 2016.