Tax & Private Clients
Brexit: Opportunities in Ceuta and Melilla for Online Operators
Teresa Valdelomar ·
The increasingly imminent outcome of the so-called “Brexit”, or the United Kingdom’s departure from the European Union (indeed, on 4 March Spain signed a tax agreement ad referendum with the United Kingdom concerning Gibraltar)[1] is forcing a considerable number of companies, including online gambling operators, to relocate elsewhere in the European Union. In the specific case of Spain, for example, Law 13/2011, regulating online gambling, only grants licences to domestic operators or those from the European Union or the European Economic Area (EEA).
In this search for new locations, three territories within Spain are positioning themselves among the most attractive, the Canary Islands, Ceuta and Melilla, which meet the necessary conditions for online gambling operators to decide to establish themselves there.
The principal reason (though not the only one) is that all three Territories have highly competitive tax regimes.
As early as 2018, we highlighted in another article the significance of the initiative introduced in the General State Budget for that year, under which taxation on online gambling for operators domiciled in Ceuta and Melilla was to be reduced by 50%. We also noted its relationship with, or coincidence in timing with, the announced Brexit.
Focusing in this article on the Autonomous Cities of Ceuta and Melilla, the recent amendment of their respective Tax Ordinances governing IPSI (the equivalent of VAT in Ceuta and Melilla) has acquired significance. Ceuta was first, applying the new IPSI rules from 31 January 2019. Melilla, for its part, did not wish to be left behind in this battle and, on 12 February 2019, published the final approval of the amendment to the tax ordinance governing this tax in the Official Gazette of that Autonomous City. But let us take each point in turn.
First, it should be noted that Law 27/2014 on Corporation Tax (hereinafter, “LIS”) provides for a 50% relief on the gross tax liability in respect of income obtained in Ceuta and Melilla. Companies need not establish their registered offices in those territories for this relief to apply, since foreign entities or entities located in the common tax territory may also benefit from it in respect of income obtained in Ceuta and Melilla. However, they must have, at a minimum, a fixed place of business in those Autonomous Cities. The relief applies to income originating in those Autonomous Cities, and it is therefore essential to have material and human resources with which to carry on the activity.
Furthermore, the LIS provides for two incentives relating to Research, Development and Innovation (R&D&I) activities. The first, known as the “patent box”, entails a reduction of up to 60% in income derived from the licensing of intangible assets. Although computer programs are not assets eligible for this reduction, the underlying principles or ideas on which such programs are built, such as algorithms or programming techniques and languages, are eligible. The second is the already familiar tax credit for carrying out R&D&I activities, an incentive which, alternatively, also applies to reductions in Social Security contributions for personnel engaged in such activities.
Consequently, although the corporation tax rate in Spain is not among the most attractive in the surrounding jurisdictions (25% as a general rule), if a company decides to relocate to Ceuta or Melilla and carries out all its operations from those territories, the resulting tax liability may be halved. This, combined with the application of various tax incentives, such as those described in relation to R&D&I activities, may bring the effective tax rate down to around 10%.
However, beyond the tax incentives provided for in the LIS itself, as noted at the beginning of this article, both Ceuta and Melilla are highly attractive destinations for online gambling operators owing to their low indirect taxation. While IPSI already had substantially lower tax rates than VAT (ranging from 0.5% to 10%, with an approximate average rate of 7%), the amendment of the IPSI Tax Ordinance of the Autonomous City of Ceuta has introduced the super-reduced rate (0.5%) for general advisory services, fraud prevention services, and data processing and information supply services in connection with online gambling operations. In a very similar manner, although with less precise wording that creates some uncertainty, the Autonomous City of Melilla establishes the super-reduced rate of 0.5% for all ancillary and supplementary management services for carrying out gambling activities.
Furthermore, for businesses generally, and not solely in relation to online gambling, the Ceuta rules provide for the application of the super-reduced rate of 0.5% to advertising and similar services, customer service and electronically supplied services (before the reform, these services were taxed, depending on their nature, at rates of 4% or 9%). Melilla, for its part, also extends this super-reduced rate of 0.5% to advertising –and marketing– services and electronically supplied services, but excludes customer service.
The result of all this is a substantial tax incentive for online gambling operators, since, for them, the VAT applicable in the common tax territory is a cost that significantly erodes business margins: it entails a 21% increase in the cost of the services they receive from third parties which, with all these measures, becomes just 0.5% of that amount.
To all the foregoing must be added what was already highlighted in the aforementioned 2018 article: since 2019 there has been a 50% reduction in Gambling Tax applicable to operators established in Ceuta and Melilla, so that the tax rate is reduced from 20% to 10% where online gambling operators have their tax domicile and “real” headquarters in those Autonomous Cities. In other words, not only must the tax domicile be formally transferred to Ceuta or Melilla, but the effective management of the company must also be conducted from that territory.
In short, both Ceuta and Melilla prove to be highly recommended destinations for online gambling operators that have to “move” from the United Kingdom.
Tax Department of Loyra Abogados
Madrid, 15 March 2019
[1] Statement issued by the government: http://www.exteriores.gob.es/Portal/es/SalaDePrensa/Comunicados/Paginas/2019_COMUNICADOS/20190304_COMU041.aspx