Gaming & Gambling
THE CNMC REPORT of 13 March 2019. Betting Regulations in Illes Balears
Carlos Lalanda ·
The state of play regarding the LGUM in the gambling sector
There are several matters on which the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC) or the Secretariat of the Market Unity Council (SECUM) have expressed their views in relation to gambling activities and the implications of the Law on the Guarantee of Market Unity (LGUM) for this sector.
In some cases, this Law has, in my humble opinion, been invoked excessively; in others, in a manner consistent with its impact on the economic sector of games of chance, which, unlike other sectors, was not mentioned during the drafting of the legislation or in its final text. It is therefore necessary to examine the provisions and requirements of the LGUM with a magnifying glass in order to find any that apply to this particular economic sector.
Previous articles (see one of them at this link), have already mentioned several Reports by those supervisory bodies which we considered to represent a truly excessive application, and others which came closer to the mark.
The judgments annulling several provisions of the LGUM
During a subsequent interlude, the well-known Constitutional Court (TC) judgments 79/2017 of 22 June and 110/2017 of 5 October were delivered. Their rulings annulling certain provisions of the LGUM might, at first sight, be understood to have diminished the weight of the various reports issued on the gambling sector. The TC annulled precisely those provisions concerning the extension of the effect of administrative action by one Autonomous Community to others (the so-called “principle of national effectiveness”, Art. 6).
However, most of the Reports issued in relation to the gambling sector invoked another principle, that of “necessity and proportionality” under Art. 5 of the LGUM, which has remained intact.
Litigation before the National High Court
In considering the “corrective” action of the CNMC and SECUM, it is important to distinguish between Reports issued under Art. 28 (merely providing guidance on the legal framework, in the nature of “Recommendations”) and those issued under Art. 26. The latter are issued in respect of acts or provisions that may be challenged in court. If they find that there is an infringement of the LGUM, the CNMC is the body with standing to bring a direct challenge before the National High Court (AN), and even to seek suspension of their enforceability (automatic under the original text, subsequently amended by the aforementioned TC judgments).
The Reports under this Art. 26 are those whose effects subsequently extend into administrative litigation, and two challenges have been brought to date: the challenge concerning the distance between gaming halls incorporated into the Regulations on gaming machines and gaming halls of the Valencian Autonomous Community (Report of 18 June 2015), which subsequently gave rise to the AN judgment of 8 March 2018, even declaring a regulatory provision null and void; and, in relation to security deposits, the challenge brought against a decision refusing to register a manufacturer in the Register of Cantabria, on the ground that it was required to provide a security deposit in addition to those previously provided in several Autonomous Communities to secure its respective registration (Report of 14 March 2016). A further challenge, not yet confirmed, arises from a Report addressing the refusal of authorisation to install betting terminals in Galicia to the proprietor of a hospitality establishment, on the ground that the Regulations require the concurrent signature of a gaming machine operating company (Report of 6 June 2017).
The Betting Regulations in the Balearic Islands, under scrutiny
Against this background, the latest report now made public, <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">UM/012/19 13 March 2019, issued under Art. 28, considers that the LGUM has been infringed in several respects relating to Decree 42/2017, of 25 August, approving the Betting Regulations in Illes Balears. On the one hand, the possible presence of two or more betting operators on the same premises with terminals in the so-called “betting areas”; and, on the other, the requirement for technical certification by a professional body in order to process projects to modify the halls, as required by Art. 23.2.d.
It is true that this is a Report issued under Art. 28 (that is, as we have said, in the form of a “Recommendation” to the body empowered to grant authorisations), but its future effect should not be disregarded on that account.
As regards the first issue, a question of interpretation is analysed in detail: whether the approach taken by the Balearic authority to Art. 21 of the Regulations is valid, namely that terminals belonging to only one operating company may be authorised on each gambling premises, and that several separate areas intended for this purpose cannot coexist. The CNMC Report maintains that, without straining the wording of the Regulations, this provision of multiple offerings is possible precisely through the application of the principles of the LGUM, which would even have given rise to a challenge to the Regulations had the contrary been expressly stated. In support of this approach, it invokes Article 16 of the LGUM (principle of freedom of economic initiative) and, once again, Art. 5 (Principle of necessity and proportionality). The view of the administrative body advocating the contrary interpretation cannot be justified on the overriding grounds of public interest relating to the protection of public health which it had invoked.
As regards the second issue, the mandatory nature of certification by a professional body, the CNMC follows the position already maintained in numerous reports on the application of Royal Decree 1000/2010 of 5 August, which regulates certification by professional bodies. It states that such certification may only be considered mandatory where certain criteria of necessity and proportionality are met. This recommendation could consequently lead, at a later stage in litigation and if a decision were issued, to an indirect challenge to the aforementioned Art. 23.2 d) of the Betting Regulations.
Madrid, 5 April 2019.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández