Gaming & Gambling

Decree-Law 1/2019, of 5 February, on urgent measures concerning gambling in Extremadura

Carlos Lalanda ·

Only yesterday I was commenting on the state of confusion, persecution and, ultimately, chaos that has taken hold in our society in relation to games of chance. Today we have another example of this.

There has just been published, without prior notice, in the Official Gazette of Extremadura (DOE) of 7-2, Decree-Law 1/2019, of 5 February, on ·\»urgent measures to promote responsible gambling”; and in this case, also as a matter of urgency, it calls for analysis and criticism.

The changes it introduces are varied, some striking, many redundant; their consequences are limited. The main surprise lies in the text itself, a verbatim copy of many articles of the Gambling Bill being processed in the Valencian Parliament at the initiative of the Generalitat. Such are the consequences of urgency. Leaving aside nuances of a political or ideological nature, I shall endeavour to focus on its legal analysis.

 Title and Explanatory Memorandum.

The first confusion to be observed lies in the very title it has been given: “promotion of responsible gambling”. Forgive the warning, but this is an initial contradiction or antinomy: a public administration does not have the power to promote responsible gambling; rather, if anything, it would have the power to prevent irresponsible gambling. I think we are off to a bad start….

Reading the successive paragraphs of the Explanatory Memorandum, various misconceptions are listed, founded solely on the abundant daily material emanating from social media, false news or news exaggerated to the extreme, to which I referred, with some examples to which I refer the reader, in a recent article . I would point out at the outset that the Decree-Law's file is not accompanied by a single piece of data, figure or document substantiating this legislative fantasy, as can be gleaned from the public consultation material which appeared the following day on Extremadura's “transparency” portal.

Some instances of overstepping powers can generally be observed, to which I shall refer later, but the most striking point is that all this reasoning is in almost schizophrenic contradiction with the public action of the Junta de Extremadura, which recently promoted the enactment of <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Law 7/2018 (LEGIO) to authorise casinos in Extremadura without spatial or temporal limits, and with special taxation close to “0”, which has led one company to have already applied for a “package of 33 casinos”. For the reader's information, there are 54 casinos open throughout Spain, and the figure for Extremadura exceeds those in Macao and Atlantic City combined, and is surpassed only by Las Vegas, Nevada, USA. I fail to understand how one thing squares with the other.

However, the principal gem is to be found in the attempt to justify the use of the Decree-Law mechanism: “as regards the principle of transparency”, neither the public consultation procedure nor the public hearing and public information procedures have been conducted, since the legislative instrument chosen, owing to its urgency, does not allow the aforementioned procedures to be conducted”: then they should have chosen another, more participatory and, while they were at it, democratic one!

Shortly after the legislation was published in the DOE, we learnt that the file was being opened to public consultation. What for? Having viewed the file “transparently after the event”, we have been able to verify and deduce that a “secret text” must indeed have been circulating around certain offices of the Junta, without any accompanying document or report, not even a reference to the Extremadura press concerning the public calamities it seeks to prevent; and that, shortly before its approval and publication, on 1 February, the Report of the General Secretariat and the almost identical Report on necessity and expediency, of the same date, were prepared, foreshadowing the Explanatory Memorandum and purporting to justify the absence of an opinion from the Economic and Social Council of Extremadura, but also of one from the Legal Office. A Friday at 13:56, with the weekend ahead; and the following Tuesday the Decree-Law is approved at the Junta's meeting. Will anything be amended if anyone makes representations?

Searching through the prior documents, now that we can, the most relevant, if not the only one, dating from before Christmas, reports on the Bill's gender impact and, after 5 pages, reaches the following conclusion:

“the legislation is gender-sensitive, inasmuch as the subject matter it addresses, the aims pursued and the measures adopted have the same impact on men as on women, since gambling activity has no gender”

We take our hats off to the Junta de Extremadura in terms of its technique of government: it has surpassed the paradigm of Trump, who governs through his Tweets after finding out what is happening through the reports of his preferred online news service; it is now possible to determine a Government's public action without listening to anyone, other than the “noise” of the Internet, to copy a text that is the intellectual property of the Generalitat Valenciana; and then to notify the Autonomous Community's Parliament of the amendment of a Law through the Official Gazette of Extremadura.

It is embarrassing that the drafter of the Explanatory Memorandum should refer to pathological gambling without having investigated how many pathological gamblers are receiving treatment in Extremadura, or what minimum data must be taken into account to form even a basic idea of the scale of this problem (very limited, incidentally), with just one reference to a Proposal for Action of 26 October 2018 approved by the Assembly of Extremadura. Without further references, it invokes “safeguarding the protection of constitutional principles and European Union law, such as guaranteeing consumer protection, avoiding the encouragement of pathological habits and behaviours , etc. and, finally, as the crowning justification, it states that the purpose is to “reduce, diversify and discourage the habit and prevent monopolistic activities in its management”.

In short, to say such things when a Law allowing unlimited casinos and taxation at “0” (LEGIO) has just been enacted in 2018, and to exempt the Lottery Points of Sale of the monopolistic SELAE from the application of the Decree-Law (Art. 41.1, para. 2), seems ironic. Of course, this last point is also copied from the Valencian text.

This entire Explanatory Memorandum exudes a paternalistic and propagandistic flavour (at times vacuous, arrogant and legally nonsensical), surely driven by electoral considerations, regarding the habits of the people of Extremadura. As stated in one paragraph, the ultimate reason for this deployment is the legislation's “protective zeal”, which can indeed be invoked as the sole legitimate purpose of administrative intervention in a business activity, technically known as the “protective purpose” (which has nothing to do with preventing illnesses or addictions). But protective…… of whom or of what…?

I think it is worth examining the content of the legislation, its purported innovations, coercive measures, exceptions and allowances, in order to reach a somewhat better-informed conclusion as to what it brings.

Content of the Decree-Law

The legislative technique consists of amending certain articles of the Gambling Law of Extremadura, which, as we know, is Law 6/1998, of 18 June, already amended several times, most recently and most significantly by Law 2/2012 of 28 June.

The “cut and paste” from the Valencian Bill is reflected in the following articles of the Extremadura Law:

Art. 6 (gambling advertising), (verbatim copy of Art. 5 of the Valencian Bill)

Art. 25 (rights and duties of participants in gambling); (likewise Arts. 12 and 13)

Art. 26 (Register of Access Restrictions), (likewise Art. 17)

Arts. 31.1 and 32.1, various new categories of offences (very serious or serious offences), (likewise Arts. 57 and 58)

Art. 36 (administrative penalties). (Likewise Arts. 61 and 63 to 67)

In addition, an Article 25 bis is added (Prohibition on participating in gambling and on accessing gambling premises and web portals); (verbatim copy of Art. 15 of the Valencian text)

and an entire Chapter VIII (On the regulation of responsible gambling) with 8 new articles. (Corresponding to Art. 2, final paragraphs, 3, 4, 18, and 52 to 54 of the Valencian Bill before the Corts.

In addition, 5 transitional provisions which, when read carefully, negate most of the intended effects, the generic repeal and implementing regulations provisions, and the commencement provision, on the following 8 February.

Only a few paragraphs of the Decree-Law escape this verbatim reproduction and are home-grown.

Since this entire mixture results in certain inaccuracies and difficulties of comprehension, I shall divide the analysis by grouping them into the following categories: “overstepping powers”, “genuine innovations” and “redundancies”; and I shall dwell on some of the more striking rules.

Overstepping powers

Among the clearly objectionable matters is the Government's attempt to influence the private lives of the people of Extremadura. All the references made to gambling over the Internet, and most of those relating to advertising in the media, are vacuous and wishful thinking, given the constitutional or practical impossibility for the Junta de Extremadura to control, limit, reduce or prohibit anything on the Internet or on Twitter or Facebook; or in commercial communications that are not wholly internal to Extremadura. It would have been more effective in this regard for the Regional Minister responsible for the Internet to have contacted the headquarters of those multinational entities in California (whose budgets are 10 times greater than Extremadura's) to try to restrict their access and use “policies”; or to have approached the Gambling Policy Council in Madrid, which we assume is already doing something about this, and on which the representatives of the Government of Extremadura have a seat and an open microphone. Or the “regulatory arm” representing the Autonomous Communities on the recently “created” Responsible Gambling Council.

We fail to understand how the Junta de Extremadura can influence or restrict the offerings received by the people of Extremadura via mobile phone, PC or tablet, or how it can apply advertising prohibitions to gambling or betting at national level or to national media without violating the distribution of powers. For the powers conferred on the Community of Extremadura and, in turn, its Government through the Statute do not concern “the lives, deeds or customs of the people of Extremadura” (which is what seems to hover over a reading of the text of the Decree-Law when it refers to gambling for money), but rather the provision of gambling services within its territory, as is the case with gaming halls, betting shops or, once again, the 33 hypothetical new casinos for which a company recently applied. The “arrogance” over powers exuded by the Decree-Law is astonishing on this point, in my humble opinion, in the light of the Spanish Constitution and the Spanish legal system, which establishes a State of Autonomous Communities decentralising services to citizens, not granting sovereign powers to the Autonomous Communities. This also applies, incidentally, to the Valencian Community and its copied Gambling Bill.

The power to authorise (or totally and absolutely prohibit) gambling establishments located in Extremadura does indeed lie with the Autonomous Community, as recognised in its Statute of Autonomy, but it does not extend to the right and freedom of the people of Extremadura to gamble, who, as well as being able to do so in any other public place if they were prohibited from doing so in Extremadura, can do so among themselves. Extremadura's own Law recalls this in the amended Law (right to gamble freely: Art. 25. e).

Thus, sifting through the legislative text here and there, I consider that most of the requirements relating to the use of the Internet by the people of Extremadura, and most of the references to the advertising of gambling, betting, or in national media, may be regarded as contrary to the Constitution and null and void. Among others, the new subparagraphs v), x) of Art. 31.1; subparagraph j) of Art. 32.1; and the whole of the new Art. 25 bis (insofar as they refer to gambling web portals). Art. 47 (insofar as it refers to web portals); Art. 6.7, if it refers to advertising of betting at national level.

It remains to be seen whether the central State will bring a conflict of powers, or, as is more usual in modern practice concerning powers, “invite” the Autonomous Community to interpret the legislation through the Extremadura–State Bilateral Commission, which is more fashionable.

Noteworthy innovations

It is worth pausing to examine which rules are genuinely new and seek to influence the gambling offering in Extremadura, which is the proper sphere of action referred to in the Statute and now in the Explanatory Memorandum. We essentially identify 4:

  • Prohibition on new authorisations for gambling premises less than 250 metres from another gambling premises already authorised. Art. 45.2. (new)
  • Prohibition on new authorisations for such premises less than 300 metres from public or private educational establishments, including universities. (Art. 45.1, new)
  • Obligation to introduce prior admission control services at gambling premises, which are not detailed and are left to subsequent implementing regulations. (Art. 47.3)
  • Prohibition (vague and confusing) of sports betting advertising (Art. 6.7). See a specific comment below.

Innovations 1 and 2 above must be examined alongside the Second, Fourth and Fifth Transitional Provisions, which contain important safeguards that are logical in a State governed by the rule of law. In other words, they do not apply to establishments already authorised (administrative logic dictates that they do not apply to applications being processed either, unless compensation is paid); but nor do they apply to renewals of those authorisations. That is to say, they do not affect the current situation, but freeze it. Consequently, no new applications may be submitted in breach of those distance restrictions from 8 February. Conversely, in view of the new Art. 32.1 l), no one will dare “not to renew” their authorisation, since they would be penalised for doing so.

Innovation 3 must be read alongside the Fourth Transitional Provision, which grants a period of 3 months to adapt gaming halls to the requirements of the Law. However, since this matter is deferred to subsequent regulations (Art. 47.3), it is a rule with which compliance is currently impossible, or compliance is left to the judgement and good faith of their operators: admission services may consist of a wide range of things: a simple counter, a moustachioed security guard, or a “virtual and intelligent” device, which do exist (everything is left to business originality and imagination, which in these cases become sharper).

Redundancies and repetitions

The other amendments included were either already in the Law or the Regulations, or state the obvious, with a few exceptions. In article order:

Advertising. All the cross-references and references to the general rules on advertising reiterate and repeat the previous regime, with some exceptions: certain betting or sporting activities, which will be considered later, and the introduction of the warning about pathological gambling in messages, the mandatory nature of which is indeed new.

The rights and obligations of gamblers (previously “users' rights and personal restrictions”). Nothing new worth noting. The people of Extremadura have the same ones as those proposed for the people of Valencia.

Prohibitions on participation. Prohibitions previously scattered and now set out in a new article (also an exact copy of the Valencian Bill being processed). (As an aside, the previous prohibition on gambling by civilian and military officials handling public funds is removed). The most urgent and media-prominent issue in this chapter remains unspecified: whether male and female participants in sporting competitions may bet on events in the “competitions” (and not only the “events” and “activities”) in which they participate.

The “Register of Access Restrictions” (to gambling, it is understood) is reduced to a definition and, once again, to implementing regulations (also a copy of the Valencian scheme, where it is called the “Register of persons excluded from access to gambling”). This introduces further confusion already criticised in other cases, since the proper course is for all Autonomous Communities to cooperate in the procedures and coordination with the prohibition and self-exclusion system put in place by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ), which even provides for a registration procedure through a simple mobile app.

The penalty regime includes some new categories of offences unrelated to the matters mentioned (for example, reducing companies' share capital below the specified thresholds is considered a very serious offence, Art. 31.1. s); and others that will have no effect until, once again, implementing regulations determine the specific requirement or conduct to be observed. In fact, all the categories of offences included are copied word for word from the Valencian Bill, in a sort of “I have this one, I do not have this one, so I shall add it” technique.

In addition to the one mentioned above, there are some very curious new categories of offences:

  • Art. 32.k). Failure to comply with opening hours for gambling establishments. A duplicate offence, because this is already regulated in Law 4/2016 on entertainment and recreational activities in Extremadura (which already states that this very conduct is a minor offence if the overrun is less than 30 minutes, and serious if greater)
  • Art. 32 l). (This is the only one not of Valencian origin). The consequence of failing to renew an authorisation is no longer merely to be left without authorisation, but also to incur a penalty (and what if the company does not wish to renew?).

Finally, the penalty regime introduces the publication (not “publicity”, which is the wrong term) of penalties imposed for very serious offences, a salutary exercise in setting an example, in this and other areas. Criticism and praise that also apply to the Valencian Bill, since it is copied from it verbatim.

Another “innovation” worth highlighting, and this one is indeed home-grown in Extremadura: the money collected from the penalties imposed will be earmarked for prevention, assistance and other action undertaken in relation to pathological gambling by the Regional Ministry responsible for addictions. This is certainly only possible if it is regarded as a “budgetary rule” and, as such, excluded from the subject matter of Decree-Laws. It goes without saying that this allocation is always at the disposal of the Assembly of Extremadura, and need only be entered in each year's Budget Law, according to the actual needs of this public service.

Continuing in textual order, the guiding principles of responsible gambling, responsible gambling policies and the prohibition of “irresponsible gambling” are just that: generic and general principles, policies and prohibitions which add no new coercive rules, but rather indeterminate legal concepts that must subsequently be given concrete form in order to attain the status of a “legal rule”. Among them there is only one (Art. 41.2, a copy of 3.3 of the Valencian Bill) that was not previously provided for in Extremadura and constitutes a genuine legal rule: the prohibition on granting loans, bonuses or free games to gambling users, although, as stated above, this prohibition can only affect land-based gambling taking place in Extremadura.

Finally, it is commendable that the regime for inspection, supervision and control (Art. 48) is clarified and detailed, even if copied from the Valencian draft, since this chapter had not hitherto been included in Extremadura and recourse had to be had to supplementary rules.

The prohibition of betting advertising: “step right up and see”

I leave the new Article 6.7 until last:

 “The development of the necessary mechanisms prohibiting advertising on kit, facilities, sponsorships or the like for all types of sports betting shall be promoted. This prohibition shall apply to all sporting categories.”

This paragraph is not in the Valencian Bill.

Read forwards and backwards, it is incomprehensible, which would go unnoticed were it not the cornerstone of the Decree-Law itself, the whole of which rests on the principal scenario depicted in the Explanatory Memorandum: the supposed “great social alarm”, above all due to the “growing influence and popularity of bookmakers” or the fact that “the sports betting sector is growing exponentially”. We are therefore obliged to scrutinise it closely, in case the cornerstone is defective and, consequently, the whole building is in danger of collapse.

Any requirement either prohibits something or does not prohibit it; it does not ramble. If, as is the case here, the requirement is diluted into the development of subsequent “mechanisms”, it actually says no more than was previously stated in this Article 6 on advertising, which was already very ambiguous. We assume that the reference to “mechanisms” is to subsequent Regulations (let us not imagine that the Junta can require the installation of inhibitor chips connected to the televisions or transistor radios of the people of Extremadura). This could already have been done before.

On a third reading of the paragraph, and changing the order of its terms, one might conclude that the intention is for it to affect advertising for all types of sports betting appearing on kit, facilities, sponsorships or “the like”. And, as regards the type of events on which bets may be placed, that it applies “to all sporting categories”.

Viewed in this way, many doubts remain: what are “facilities”? All installations in Extremadura, such as cranes? Only those belonging to sports clubs? Sports venues too? What is “the like”? Can SELAE's football pools no longer be advertised in Extremadura? Can Extremadura de Almendralejo no longer display its sponsor's name from tomorrow? Can Second Division teams visit Extremadura at its ground wearing their sponsors' shirts?

Since, moreover, the new Art. 6.1 again refers to a regulatory regime for advertising, and the statutory offence covering advertising (as amended) continues to consist of the absence of “due authorisation or outside the limits set”, it seems impossible to us to determine, as matters stand, what may or may not lawfully be done in these times of confusion.

If we add to this that, as stated, the Autonomous Community's powers cannot encroach upon the State's powers to regulate gambling and betting at national level and, consequently, its advertising throughout the national territory, including Extremadura, the regulatory chaos is absolute on this point.

Reasons for urgency

The approval of a Decree-Law can only be justified by reasons of urgency, as the Explanatory Memorandum acknowledges and takes pains to state. Otherwise, it could be deemed unconstitutional.

The subsequent public consultation procedure opened the day after its publication in the DOE confuses us, both as to its timing — should it not have taken place before the legislative procedure? — and as to its substance: there are only two terse Reports on gender treatment and on the absence of expenditure effects, and 2 almost identical Reports dated 2 days before approval, which form the basis of its Explanatory Memorandum. There are no documents or studies, no Reports from the General Advisory Office, the Economic Council, the Consultative Council or the Personero del Común (well, the latter still exists only in the text of the Statute), because it is asserted that they are not required. There should, by contrast, have been a copy of the Valencian Bill copied and used, in case any typographical error in relation to it is identified.

But, having seen what we have seen, apart from the undocumented Extremadura scenario on which the whole argument is built……. what actual immediate effects does the legislation produce that address the causes invoked?

The new rules on distances do not entail the elimination of any existing offering; this measure could have been implemented by a simple Resolution of the Governing Council, as the Government of Murcia recently did, for example, with a single two-line article.

As regards strengthening access controls at physical premises, the regime for betting advertising and that for the Register of Access Restrictions, we await future implementing regulations. No Law is needed for this, still less a Decree-Law. In the absence of these rules, the new categories of offences v) and w) of Art. 31 are unworkable.

We have also established that, in reality, many amended articles neither alter nor replace the rules previously in force. Gambling principles and policies may be highly commendable declarations and statements, but they require rules to give them concrete form.

Nor does the immediate opening of the 33 casinos applied for appear imminent, for then it would indeed be important to know, for example, that money cannot be lent to users, of course.

Explanations based on other, extra-legal grounds for urgency can always be advanced: for example, the forthcoming regional elections in May. This is what can be discerned in the final Reports, when they recall that “if the ordinary legislative procedure were used ……. its approval during this parliamentary term would not be feasible and they would be unnecessarily delayed”.

But that is no longer for me to analyse.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

10 February 2018

More publications