Gaming & Gambling
\»De-escalation\» of Gambling Premises: Encounters for the Third Phase
Carlos Lalanda ·
In a recent commentary analysing the Phases and Terms of the measures for the resumption of the various economic activities suspended by Royal Decree 463/2020, which introduced the current state of alarm, we left the possibility of reopening premises conducting gambling activities until a phase subsequent to Phase I, with the exception of SELAE and ONCE lottery sales outlets, which are already permitted to open in the first phase. And we left open the possibility that gambling premises might begin taking their first steps towards resuming activity at least in Phase II.
Well, under Order SND/414/2020, of 16 May (again, published on the Saturday itself, taking effect on the Monday), this possibility has initially been ruled out, and unless it is amended shortly, it will be necessary to wait until Phase III.
The sudoku of dates, territories and activities in \»de-escalation\»
It must be borne in mind (and with considerable mental concentration beforehand) that this Order SND/414 regulates the detailed characteristics of the so-called “Phase II” (which, in reality, like the others, until its publication in the Official State Gazette (BOE), is no more than a Government Power Point with no legal force), and that it enters into force on Monday 18 May at 00:00, but on that date only for the islands of Gomera, Hierro, Graciosa and Formentera.
As of today, 17 May, these islands have already spent 2 weeks in Phase I (and, under an initial guideline of 15 days per Phase, were already due to move on); however, the remaining Territories in Phase I still have another week under it and, therefore, can be expected to enter Phase II next Monday, the 25th.
But there are still territories (Madrid, Barcelona, some areas of Castilla y León) where we remain in Phase 0, albeit in a relaxed form.
The new Order, in turn, amends certain aspects of the previous Order regulating Phase I (Order SND/399); for example, the number of people who may gather outdoors for cultural events or performances in general is 200, but only 20 are permitted in Castilla La Mancha, 30 in the Valencian Autonomous Community and 50 in Murcia (do not ask me why).
In short, this entire process of de-escalation by “Phases” brings us into a changing scenario which neither corresponds to what was initially envisaged nor remains static, but instead moves \»to the rhythm of the official gazette”, from week to week.
And this is what must be expected in relation to all economic sectors, including the gambling sector.
And in this particular sudoku, there is an additional, more important condition: the approval (or non-approval) of the extension of the state of alarm every 15 days, which is therefore the premise underpinning this entire order, or disorder, of Phases. If the next extension is not approved on Wednesday, as the Government intends to request, on 23 May (at 24:00) this sudoku will have ended (and another, even more complex one would begin).
Gambling premises are not included in Phase II
I have already indicated that the numerous provisions of this new Order do not mention premises devoted exclusively to gambling operations (casinos, bingo halls, betting premises, gaming halls); nor is any provision made for gaming machines to be installed in hospitality establishments.
Although, for the latter, the approach remains to open premises to the public, but only for table service (which suggested that gaming machines could only be accessed in Phase III, which includes bar service), this was already envisaged in the general scheme of Phases. Nevertheless, it was more foreseeable that gambling premises would be able to enter Phase II, not because they were mentioned, since they were not, but because other social or economic activities of a similar nature or involving larger numbers of attendees were expected to do so. This was the case for cinemas and theatres, conference halls, or even places of worship, for which reopening scenarios with occupancy limits are envisaged, stricter in Phase II and more relaxed in Phase III.
Yet they are not expressly mentioned in any case, which makes any other interpretation very difficult or impossible, given that the Annex to Royal Decree 463/2020 imposing the state of alarm expressly mentions these activities (or rather, the premises where they take place) in the list of those suspended, and that the Orders defining both Phase I and Phase II clearly apply “to the activities covered by this Order” (Article 2.1), and only to those regulated therein and subsequently listed one by one.
In short, premises conducting gambling activities are not included in Phase II, whether we like it or not, and their proprietors appear bound to wait until the Third Phase. They may always lodge an appeal, of course (third final provision), which in these cases is somewhat akin to the popular saying “complain to the master armourer”. It is also possible, and cannot be ruled out in advance, that complaints and claims might be accepted in the weekly review by the customary health conclave.
Some uncertainty and several clues
As matters stand, we can nevertheless identify a doubtful point and a number of measures which are refining those that will apply when, at last, provisions are introduced for the establishments and activities to which we refer.
Reviewing the numerous measures and concepts approved in this new Order, and comparing it with the first, we might tease out the implications of certain concepts:
1.Some gaming halls are situated in shopping centres and, as an initial position and with considerable caution, it could be argued that they are authorised to open. Article 12 b) permits the opening of \»commercial premises\» situated within them, subject to an occupancy limit of 40% of their total capacity. Can they be understood to be included here? …… Although gambling premises do not technically fall within the category of “commercial” premises, the fact is that, in ordinary terms, this is how they are characterised in these centres, and indeed the Order does not exclude them from this initial reopening in the following paragraph c), which refers only to hospitality and catering activities; nor does it do so in paragraph d), which refers to recreational areas that in fact usually form part of the common areas.
2.There are numerous measures which must accompany reopening and which again give us an indication of those that will have to be implemented when gambling premises open, in whichever Phase that may be: hygiene and prevention measures provided for, once again, in Article 6 (which includes few amendments compared with the previous provision, for example, and curiously, removing the obligation to clean and disinfect toilets at least 6 times a day); widespread references to maintaining a distance of 2 metres between customers (although, we reiterate, in places of religious worship, people seated on benches must be 1 metre apart); maximum occupancy percentages in this Phase II are generally set at 40% of capacity (retail, hospitality); but for cultural activities such as exhibitions, cinemas, theatres, visits to monuments, etc., the limit remains at 1/3 (that is, 33.33%); and 30% for swimming pools. Under this heading of monitoring attendee capacity, there is some mention of the obligation to implement systems allowing numbers to be counted and capacity monitored (Articles 16 and 17, f), and of measures to organise movement within the premises. Here and there, specific cleaning measures appear which could well be taken into account for any premises open to the public, in relation to sanitary fittings, taps and toilet door handles (every hour, Article 13.2), or the disinfection of devices after each customer has handled them (Article 15.5, second paragraph). Or, in general, in relation to precautions concerning workers.
3.All the foregoing provisions, precautions and analogies, although they are being set out in greater detail, should become clearer if the forthcoming Orders include specific measures tailored to the reality of gambling premises, their layout and their use by customers, which has its own particular features compared with other activities, however similar they may be.
Online gambling and lotteries, at half throttle
Unlike gambling in the premises mentioned above, the restrictions imposed no longer apply to the other two major sectors of gambling operations, namely online gambling and lotteries.
In the case of online gambling, by its very “remote” nature, it was not affected by the suspension measures adopted, even though, in the case of sports betting, the suspension of almost all events on which bets could be placed created a substantial gap in the offering.
In the case of lotteries, although the draws themselves were not suspended by the Government, the respective operators agreed to suspend them because of the difficulty of accessing sales outlets (it was never clear whether or not these sales outlets were included in the Annex of premises whose activities were suspended). Moreover, these premises are already authorised in Phase I, subject only to the general restrictions concerning social distancing, hygiene and cleaning (although only those for “State” gambling, overlooking those at Autonomous Community level, such as EAJA).
However, irrespective of the fact that there is no impediment to the full operation of the respective products in those two activities, the prohibition on commercial communications remains in force in almost all forms and time slots, since Royal Decree-Law 11/2020 so provided for all of them (Article 35, to which we referred in <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">another earlier commentary ). Until the state of alarm is lifted. And this is a significant restriction on the deployment of the offering, which in both cases depends on substantial advertising and promotional campaigns for games, brands, events and draws.
Furthermore, unless another urgent Royal Decree-Law provides otherwise, public announcements of SELAE and ONCE draws (and prizes) are restricted to night-time hours (from 01:00 to 05:00). In the case of ONCE, there also remains the option, agreed in the Concession Agreement, of publishing the results in the BOE, as in the past.
Madrid, 17 May 2020.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández
Loyra abogados
www.loyra.com