Gaming & Gambling
Loyra Abogados : The Royal Decree on Commercial Communications
Patricia Lalanda, Cristina Romero, Fernando Martín ·
Background
Royal Decree 958/2020, of 3 November, on commercial communications relating to gambling activities (Royal Decree on Commercial Communications) was challenged by several associations in the gambling and betting industry and the audiovisual media sector, as well as by other interested parties.
The Royal Decree on Commercial Communications sought to implement certain provisions laid down in Law 13/2011, of 27 May, on the regulation of gambling (Gambling Law). In particular, it focused on implementing, through regulations, the articles relating to commercial communications concerning gambling activities provided for in Article 7.
The question of constitutionality referred by the Supreme Court
During the proceedings challenging the Royal Decree, the Supreme Court decided to refer a question of constitutionality to the Constitutional Court, as it considered that, through Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law, the legislature had abdicated its responsibility in favour of the regulatory power, which is not consistent with the Constitution.
In other words, Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law allowed Garzón's ministry to regulate gambling advertising, which, by its nature and because of its connection with freedom of enterprise, a fundamental right proclaimed by the Constitution, should have been regulated not by a ministry, but by Parliament through legislation.
This incidental issue was resolved by the Constitutional Court in its judgment of 22 November 2023, which ruled that the insertion of Article 7 bis into the Gambling Law – an article which copied what was already laid down in Article 9 of the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications and which was inserted by Law 23/2022, of 2 November (that is, when the challenge to the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications was already under way) – addressed the concerns about the lack of clear guidelines in gambling advertising legislation which the Supreme Court had raised. For further details, we refer to our analysis: https://www.loyra.com/comentario-sobre-la-sentencia-del-tribunal-constitucional-de-22-de-noviembre-de-2023-que-declara-la-extincion-por-desaparicion-de-su-objeto-de-la-cuestion-de-inconstitucionalidad-consecuencia-de-la-2/.
Following the Constitutional Court's judgment, the case was returned to the Supreme Court for the proceedings to continue.
The Supreme Court's judgment
Criticism of deficient legislative drafting
We have now learned of the Supreme Court's judgment definitively determining the challenge to the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications. In this judgment, of 2 April 2024, the Supreme Court declares the following provisions of the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications null and void: Article 13, paragraphs 1 and 3; Article 15; Article 23, paragraph 1; Article 25, paragraph 3; Article 26, paragraphs 2 and 3, dismissing the challenge in all other respects, without making an express order for costs against any of the parties.
The Supreme Court's judgment begins by disagreeing with the Constitutional Court's ruling and severely criticising the legislative drafting employed in this case, in particular the attempt to remedy, through Article 7 bis (inserted, as we have said, in 2022), possible defects in Article 7.2 of the Gambling Law, which purportedly provided the legal basis for the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications.
In this regard, the judgment under analysis has declared that the restrictions on advertising in the gambling sector laid down by the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications cannot be legitimised (or corrected) retroactively by subsequent legislative amendments, as suggested by the insertion of Article 7 bis into the Gambling Law by Law 23/2022. Under the principle that certain matters are reserved to statute, the Supreme Court states, the absence of an adequate legal basis at the time of the adoption of the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications would render the restrictive rules it imposed null and void. Thus, the Supreme Court emphasises that provisions and acts which are null and void cannot be rectified retrospectively, and rules restricting individual rights, as the Royal Decree does, cannot be imposed (or corrected) retroactively. It also stresses that the new provisions – and prohibitions – introduced in 2022 do not significantly affect the assessment of the lawfulness of the challenged restrictions in the aforementioned Decree.
The Supreme Court annuls essential provisions of the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications
The Court annuls Article 13, paragraphs 1 and 3, which concerned commercial communications relating to promotions, requiring them to be directed solely at existing customers, to appear in specific sections of online platforms or on authorised premises, to avoid misleading messages about offers being free of charge, to omit testimonials, not to be based on the player's skill and to provide detailed information on the conditions of participation and benefits.
The Supreme Court annuls these paragraphs because it finds no legal basis for imposing these restrictions, which affect the very essence of commercial advertising, whose purpose is to offer and promote a product or service in order to attract new customers. A general prohibition of this kind does not allow its scope to be confined to a specific type of promotion which is particularly harmful or targets vulnerable groups, and therefore cannot be regarded as a proportionate measure limited to offers and practices which are highly addictive and dangerous for groups at risk.
The Court annuls Article 15, which restricted the appearance of public figures or characters in gambling and betting advertising, prohibiting their use subject to certain exceptions: where they become well known as a result of the advertising campaign itself, where they commentate on live events or present competitions in audiovisual media, in compliance with the specific rules applicable to each case.
The Supreme Court annuls this provision because it considers that this prohibition has no legal basis and is ultra vires (it goes beyond what the Law permits) in relation to the delegation made by the Gambling Law, and has no legal basis in the other statutory provisions in force at the time this Royal Decree was adopted.
The Court annuls Article 23, paragraph 1, concerning commercial communications in information society services, which regulated the dissemination of gambling advertising through digital services, allowing it only under certain conditions.
The basis for annulling this provision is that the Supreme Court considers that the restrictions laid down in this article and paragraph, once again, have no legal basis, and that it is not sufficient for the Royal Decree on Commercial Communications to invoke the protection of minors, since advertising cannot be restricted generally across an entire medium on the grounds that it might be used by minors.
The Court annuls Article 25, paragraph 3, concerning the rules on the dissemination of audiovisual commercial communications through video-sharing platform services, which provided that audiovisual commercial communications by gambling operators could only be made through accounts or channels on video-sharing platforms whose principal activity was to provide information on gambling activities in accordance with the Gambling Law, and also laid down additional requirements for such advertising.
This provision is annulled because, according to the Supreme Court, this restriction has no legal basis whatsoever, given the general scope with which it is framed.
Finally, the Court annuls paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 26 of the Royal Decree, concerning the specific rules on commercial communications on social media, which required that the dissemination of gambling advertising on social media be permitted only for followers of official accounts of operators or authorised entities, individuals with an active interest in gambling who can withdraw that interest, and registered customers. The paragraph requiring that social media accounts or channels could only disseminate commercial communications by gambling operators if their principal activity was to provide information on gambling – within the scope of the Gambling Law – and also laying down additional requirements for such advertising is likewise annulled.
The Supreme Court considers that the restrictions contained in the annulled paragraphs, like the preceding ones, have no legal basis in the legislation in force at the time the regulation was issued and must therefore be annulled.
Appeals and next steps
We consider this to be a final judgment against which no appeal lies and that, accordingly, the restrictions concerned are annulled with effect from its date of publication, namely 10 April 2024.
We shall see what decisions the government takes in response to this serious setback.
About LOYRA ABOGADOS
At LOYRA ABOGADOS, for more than 40 years, we have distinguished ourselves through our in-depth specialisation in constitutional law and gambling regulation, which enables us to provide detailed and rigorous analyses of complex cases such as the one examined in this article. Our experience is reflected not only in this examination, but also in the successes achieved in similar cases in which we have firmly defended our clients' rights in the face of challenging legislation or administrative action. We invite interested parties to contact us through our website or by arranging a consultation to explore how we can assist in specific legal situations. At LOYRA ABOGADOS, we are committed to protecting our clients' legal interests through a proactive and strategic approach.
GAMBLING TEAM
LOYRA ABOGADOS