Gaming & Gambling

A new decree submitted for consultation

Carlos Lalanda ·

With the effects of the recent Royal Decree on Commercial Communications for Gambling Activities not yet digested, the Ministry of Consumer Affairs is preparing and submitting a new Decree for preliminary consultation, which this time will develop two disparate categories of subject matter:

  • The regulation of “safer environments” for online gambling at national level.
  • The distribution of a portion of Gambling Tax (Sixth Additional Provision of the Gambling Law).

As these are two radically different matters, they should be addressed separately:

<span style=\" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">The so-called “safer environments” for online gambling

 On this first point, the initiative seeks to address three aspects, described verbatim as follows:

“1. Strengthen operators’ knowledge of their player base from the perspective of safe or responsible gambling.

2- Strengthen the obligations to provide general information to participants in games;

3- Strengthen existing responsible or safe gambling measures, with particular attention to players exhibiting risk behaviours, combining preventive, awareness-raising, intervention and control actions, as well as remediation of the negative effects caused.”

Well, as for “strengthening”, one can “strengthen” as much as one wishes, but the obligations imposed on those subject to administrative intervention already seem to us to be plentiful in the various regulatory provisions of higher or lower rank identified by the initiative itself: in Royal Decree 1613/2011 on technical approvals; in Royal Decree 1614/2011 on the licensing regime, but also in the Orders issuing Calls for Licence Applications, which required operators to build an entire ecosystem of prevention, safeguards and information aimed at players, in addition to those included in all the Ministerial Orders governing each specific game (up to 14); and in the various lower-ranking Resolutions of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) itself on the technical specifications of platforms, such as those of 6 November 2011, 12 July 2012, 31 October 2018, etc. Lastly, and as if this were not enough, the recently approved Royal Decree 958/2020 includes an entire Title II devoted to this purpose, adding several mechanisms related to Article 8 of the Gambling Law, under the heading: “Active policies for user information and protection” (Articles 29 to 35); among other things, these articles increase the obligations to provide information to players, require the appointment of a kind of officer dedicated to responsible gambling, or the implementation of specific software to detect risk behaviours among users. It also includes a specific amendment to Article 36 of Royal Decree 1614/2011 on limits on players’ deposits and self-exclusions, and removes the possibility of offering free games to non-customers     What more can be added to this?

In the absence of a specific text, which has not yet been set out at this stage of the procedure, it is very difficult or impossible to express an opinion on the Ministry’s intention. We shall see.

What seems much more important to me, and must be pointed out, is the glaring absence of a statutory basis for penalties for failure to comply with any obligation imposed in this area of player protection within this context of “social responsibility” provided for in Article 8 of the Law. This omission appears to be in the process of being remedied by the proposed amendment to the Gambling Law through the Law on the Prevention of and Fight against Tax Fraud, currently before Parliament, which seeks to introduce a new category of infringement (a serious infringement), consisting of operators’ failure to comply with, or breach of, the obligations imposed in this respect. This has not hitherto been classified as such.

Thus, in this first chapter of the Consultation, we shall have to wait for the specific text of the proposed “reinforcements”, and also for the legislative amendment to be approved, since otherwise the intervention effort will be fruitless and non-compliance will have no consequences.

The distribution of a portion of the revenue from the Tax on Gambling Activities (Sixth Additional Provision of the Law). The “return to sport” of tax revenue from betting.

This other matter that the proposed new Royal Decree seeks to regulate seems to me much easier to categorise, in view of the recent and more distant background to the issue: we are facing a genuine entelechy or Greek aporia, which in an earlier commentary we described as something akin to the “biblical miracle of the loaves and fishes”.

 Despite the intellectual efforts of some to categorise and defend the “return to sport” from betting (which essentially means reallocating and handing over, through taxes, part of the profits of the business generated by this activity), making this distribution or reallocating it by means of a Regulation, as expressly indicated in the Sixth Additional Provision of the Law since its 2012 wording, seems a titanic task that cannot be resolved for now. In my view, the situation is fundamentally flawed, in seeking to implement through regulations a distribution which, under the original wording, required a genuine formal parliamentary decision by Parliament. A genuine case of “kicking the ball down the pitch”. Or … “let someone else distribute it!”.

This issue already arose during the passage of the Law through Parliament in 2011, when the intention was to introduce into our legal system a mechanism that has found a place in foreign legal systems, such as the French system, where part of the tax on horse-race betting is returned to racecourses; or in recent betting legislation in Colombia or Brazil, where Gambling Tax revenue is applied directly to the budgets of healthcare or other institutions, including the gambling police.

The formula commonly known as the “return to sport” or “allocation to charitable or social purposes” is widely used as a lure to make new legislation on betting or games of chance more palatable, and to illustrate the benefits of collecting new taxes on gambling, a kind of justification or argumentative incentive often used by legislators in different parts of the world, almost always with exaggerated promises of additional revenue, whether or not appropriate to their respective legal systems.

In ours, this “à la carte distribution” of the Tax conflicts with a general budgetary principle, namely the “non-earmarking of revenue” for specific expenditure, a general principle about which one could theorise at length, but on which we cannot dwell here; a reference to Article 27.3 of the General Budgetary Law will suffice:

“Article 27.3.

The resources of the State, those of each of its autonomous bodies and those of the entities forming part of the State public sector whose budgets are subject to expenditure limits shall be used to meet their respective obligations as a whole, unless their earmarking for specific purposes is established by law”.

In other words, and in plain English, it is the law that must decide what specifically the revenue is earmarked for, not a Regulation. And the need for statutory approval is such that the Gambling Law itself sets out, in full detail and without delegating the matter to regulations, another “return”, namely that established in respect of revenue from the Tax on Gambling Activities (IAJ) derived from football pools, which originated long before the Gambling Law, and not as the “distribution of a tax”, but of the operator’s (the State’s) own receipts. When the operator was also converted into a public limited company (SELAE) in 2011, the only formula for “continuing to return” part of the receipts from football pools profits was to earmark part of the Gambling Tax levied on SELAE in respect of these and other traditional pool bets. This first “return” and its percentage distribution are set out in Law 13/2011 itself (Third Additional Provision, paragraph 2):

“a) 49.95% for the Provincial Councils, through the respective Autonomous Communities.

b) 45.50% for the Liga Nacional de Fútbol Profesional.

c) 4.55% for the Real Federación Española de Fútbol, to be allocated to non-professional football.”

The Tax is already “allocated” and “distributed” by the Law. And it cannot be distributed twice.

In addition to the Tax collected from football pools and its earmarked distribution discussed above, revenue from the Tax on Online Gambling Activities, derived from betting or other games of chance, is also “distributed” and transferred under the Law to the Autonomous Communities where the player or group of resident players from whom it originates resides (Article 48.11). This can be explained in many ways, but the main explanation is very simple: for a long time now, the delicate system for financing the Autonomous Communities has provided for the assignment of taxes derived from gambling. A criterion other than residence could have been adopted, but that is the one in place, and it has given rise to complex administrative situations where residents are from the Basque Country or Navarre (as the criterion arising from their respective Economic Agreements applies, which had to be amended).

Moreover, this earmarking and criterion could only be justified as “transitional earmarking”, pending a more comprehensive and definitive resolution of its inclusion in the system for financing the Autonomous Communities.  The Sixth Transitional Provision also recalls, on the one hand, that Gambling Taxation is included in the regime for assigning taxes to the Autonomous Communities and that, consequently, the definitive solution for the assignment of this IAJ will come when the new financing framework is adopted.

The two connected provisions (Article 48.11 and the Sixth Transitional Provision) say something along the following lines: “Let us send a cheque to each Autonomous Community for now, using that quantification parameter, until we resolve the entire problem of financing the Autonomous Communities”

And this cheque has been sent quarterly ever since, while the structure and Law on the Financing of the Autonomous Communities, as we know from recent parliamentary reminders, remain unresolved.

This is the position, and the same as it was in 2012, but the Tax revenue is already allocated and distributed by the Law itself, and cannot be distributed again. Nor are we dealing with a new tax. This is the conclusion I reached more than three years ago (see this link: “IAJ: the miracle of the loaves and fishes”) , when a parliamentary group came up with the idea of bringing this issue before the Congress of Deputies, which duly took the bait and solemnly resolved to call upon the Government to implement this Sixth Additional Provision.

Even the acting Ombudsman himself has stirred up this matter in response to certain complaints, falling into the simplistic approach of calling upon the Ministry of Consumer Affairs in this regard, when it clearly has no competence whatsoever over the distribution of taxes. Against this background, and more besides, hopeful potential recipients of the “return” have in recent days reminded the Government of it and requested it (a kind of “we want what is ours!!”), and the DGOJ itself has not known how to respond to them, whereupon they have brought a claim before the courts (which serve every purpose, even throwing a tantrum).

In short, regulating the so-called “return to sport” is a matter of budgetary significance requiring a formal Act of Parliament to allocate the distribution; and, as matters stand, the amendment of another part of the Gambling Law, that concerning the collection of IAJ, and in turn the amendment of the Regime for Financing the Autonomous Communities and Assigning Taxes, which in turn requires approval by Organic Law. This last task, at present, although also very much in vogue, presupposes that many political parties, including regionalist, nationalist and pro-independence parties, align themselves in agreement. To take part of the cheque away from the Basque Country or Catalonia, for example, and give it to Villaverde CF.

Who knows, football can move mountains!!

Lastly, there is the problem inherent in any distribution:  how is it to be distributed? Who gets more, and who gets less? Do we distribute it by the type of sport on which bets are placed? Whether it is Olympic or not, amateur or professional, male or female, able-bodied or disabled, mental or physical? To be allocated to clubs, federations or elite athletes? Who is responsible for distributing it? And, as we anticipated… do we stop distributing the remittance to the Autonomous Communities?

Too many interests and parties involved, too many half-empty treasury coffers, for this proposed new “distribution” to find any path towards a fair and equitable solution.

As with the other matter submitted to Public Consultation, we are eager to see the text on distribution that the Ministry of Consumer Affairs will propose,  so that we can express a definitive opinion.

Madrid, 20 December 2020,

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Loyra Abogados (www.loyra.com).

More publications