Gaming & Gambling
Overflowing “liquidity” (on the subject of online poker).
Carlos Lalanda ·
On 15 January, the Resolution of the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ) of 29 December (not a Ministerial Order), which allows Spanish online operators to offer so-called international “liquidity” in online poker, was published in the Official State Gazette (BOE). Spanish and, for the time being, French players sharing games. This brings to a close a protracted and tiresome story that has long been our daily fare in industry forums and news bulletins.
For its part, the French regulator has also begun granting individual licences to its operators for this form of gambling.
The leading online poker operator has already welcomed this and has begun offering this new form of gambling, as befits a diligent businessperson. However ….. is all of this legally uncontroversial…?
Could Spanish and French players not previously play together in the same games or tournaments?
If a Spaniard goes to France, or a French person to Spain, there is not, nor has there ever been, any legal impediment to entering a casino and Spanish and French players playing in the same game, or to participating in a poker tournament. On the contrary, in 1977 many Spaniards travelled to casinos in the south of France; and the legislation approving the decriminalisation of gambling in Spain in 1977 stated in its Explanatory Memorandum that one of the reasons, perhaps the most important, was to encourage foreigners, including French people, to visit the new Spanish casinos.
However, the legal regime is different where there is no “physical movement”, because, unlike the territorial power of the State (France is sovereign over French territory, Spain over Spanish territory, and the USA over North Americans), a second power comes into play: the sovereignty of each State over its own nationals: France may restrict the freedom of French people to bet; and Spain that of Spaniards. The prohibition of cross-border gambling appears clear: until now, both States had so stipulated through their respective Gambling Laws, passed by their Parliaments, in relation to online gambling: a French player could not and cannot receive an offer or play in a game organised by an entity that is not authorised in France; and the same applies to a Spanish player (Article 39(a) and Article 2(1)(d) of Law 13/2011 on Gambling). Hence both Administrations strive to pursue and impose criminal (France) or administrative (Spain) penalties on the organisers and providers of online gambling (not on citizens) where they are not licensed in their respective countries (the concept of “European mutual recognition” of these authorisations does not apply here, as the Court of Justice of the European Union has repeatedly stated).
This sovereign restriction over persons exists for various historical reasons, but, like the tablets of Moses, they can be reduced to two:
- Monetary reasons: preventing the movement of pools of money to other States: in Spain, at least since Carlos III, the simple intention was to prevent subjects' money from flowing into the coffers of monopolies that financed other States;
- Tax reasons: ensuring that the taxes ultimately paid by the organisers (which are usually substantial) remain within the territory of the citizens placing the bets. A paradigmatic example: the recent British change in online gambling towards “point-of-consumption taxation”.
In short, and until now, Spanish and French players could share a poker game if they travelled physically, but not online… What, then, has changed?
What is a poker game with “shared international liquidity”?
1.First, we must consider what a poker game is. Although dissecting it may be a euphemism, a poker game is a game of “chance”, played with cards (even though “skill” influences the outcome to some extent). Several players take part in the game, betting greater or lesser amounts (there may be several “hands”), and once the game is over, the winner receives a prize equivalent to the total amount wagered by everyone, less a commission (in English: “rake”) for the operator that has brought them together at its table. The losers, the others, lose everything they have wagered. “Liquidity” is a term that in Spanish is equivalent to the “pool” of wagers, and in a poker game this liquidity depends on how much money the players wager; it is normally a “pot”. It is logical that this “liquidity” should increase as the opportunity to bring players together expands, so these opportunities increase when the game is offered and played on the Internet, and even more so if all possible players from one country, or several countries, are potentially admitted. In this case, there may be games, albeit few, in which liquidity or a pool of several thousand euros is at stake. As for the players, there are as many as can fit at a virtual table; and there is still 1 winner, while the remaining players lose (e.g. 1 wins and 8 lose).
2. A “poker tournament” is another matter. Poker tournaments consist of a succession of games, normally on a knockout basis, which conclude with one or more players being declared the winner. In a tournament, what each player wins or loses does not correspond to the betting hands they have played, but to a prize that depends on the pool of “entry fees”, which in turn acts as a “gambling pool” or “prize pool”. The pool or liquidity is made up of all the “entry fees” paid by all the players who are to participate in that tournament. Thus, the “prize” is obtained from the sum of the tournament participants' “entry fees”, less the commission or rake of the operator that organised the tournament. The participant who wins the tournament takes all (or part, if there is a prize scale, since prizes may be awarded not only to one player but to several) of the prize pool or liquidity, and those who lose, namely the remaining players, lose their “entry fee”. In this case, the proportion of winners to losers is very different from that among players in an “ordinary game. For example, in a tournament, 3 win and 2,000 lose.
In this case, it is much more feasible for the “pool or liquidity” to increase in “online poker tournaments”, and even more so in cross-border online poker tournaments (e.g. tournaments in which Spanish and French players may register).
This, then, is the principal context and significance of so-called “poker with shared international liquidity”: poker tournaments
3. In addition to “international”, it is essential to add the expression “shared” in order to understand this phenomenon technically, since “international liquidity” (without qualification) exists where several players from different countries participate in the same game or tournament, and this can happen relatively without difficulty, at least under the Spanish Gambling Law, which allows players of other nationalities to register within the operator's system.
4. Ultimately, we are left with the most accurate of the terms we use (albeit still including the unnecessary Anglicism): poker played through the online channel, using shared international liquidity (and, for now, between Spain and France only).
Spanish law, unlike French law, neither regulates nor authorises “shared international liquidity”.
In France, the French Gambling Law expressly provides for the possibility of sharing pools of wagers, subject to a prior Agreement with countries within the framework of the European Union, and ARJEL may act in such cases “on behalf of the State….” (Law No 2010-476 of 12 May 2010):
“14. II. …the Online Gambling Regulatory Authority may authorise an operator holding the approval provided for in Article 21 to offer players holding a validated account on a site covered by that approval the opportunity to participate in the circle games defined in the same first paragraph with players holding an account opened on a site approved by a Member State of the European Union or a State party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area.
(…)
34 V. ― For the purpose of monitoring operators' compliance with legislative and regulatory provisions and the clauses of the specifications, the President of the Authority may conclude agreements on behalf of the State with the gambling regulatory authorities of other Member States of the European Community or other States party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area, in order to exchange the results of checks carried out by those authorities and by the Authority itself in respect of online gambling or betting operators.
This is not the case in Spain. The Transitional Provision of Royal Decree 1614/2011 states that “international liquidity” will be regulated at a later date…. a matter on which the Law says nothing, nor is there any delegation or authorisation to regulate it, which would have entailed defining, at a minimum:
- The requirements for moving these pools “outside the national territory” of the jurisdiction.
- The criteria for applying special taxes to the organising businesses.
The same can be said of other pools, such as those for pool betting on horse racing, as of poker.
Only an amendment to Spanish law would support this power, and, in the meantime, only an International Treaty between Spain and France could remove this impediment. We may be told that nobody challenged the Transitional Provision of Royal Decree 1614/2011 at the time, or the Agreement signed with France, or now the DGOJ Resolution of 29 December 2017…… for now.
The precedents concerning “shared international liquidity” in lottery games such as Euromillón or Eurojackpot do not escape this criticism, with one qualification: when the “Agreements” concerning those draws were signed, they were signed by representatives of the respective “State Monopoly Bodies” organising the draws in their own territory (that is, between genuine States acting as gambling businesses), which does not spare them the criticism but perhaps mitigates it (or aggravates it, depending on one's perspective).
The Resolution now adopted by the DGOJ neither identifies nor resolves the problems of the “movement of pools”, or that of the connecting factor for taxing powers; it merely seeks to ensure the “transparency of the system”, focusing on security measures for the IT systems on which the games are played.
The authorisations required to begin operating this form of poker
It is instructive to review the “authorisation threads” used by operators in this case.
According to the DGOJ Resolution, in Spain it is not necessary to grant operators an individual authorisation to begin operating this form of gambling; rather, current holders of online poker licences may add it to their offering (following a prior “technical modification” of their system). In France, both are necessary.
The DGOJ Resolution has the status of a “technical rule”, which states that poker operators are permitted to offer this form of gambling, and indeed some are already offering it, and must therefore already have obtained approval for the software and technical system that enables it, barely a week after its publication in the BOE. In France, it is on record that at least one of them has already done so.
We are therefore not dealing with a “General Regulatory Provision”; rather, the Resolution derives from the DGOJ's power to issue “technical resolutions” under Article 8 of Royal Decree 1613/2011, initially vested in a National Gambling Commission established by the Law and replaced by the current DGOJ. One should not imagine that a lengthy procedure was necessary for its adoption, or that its drafting was complex. The only safeguard on record is a “report from the Legal Advisory Service”.
Following the thread, the commercial offering we are currently seeing is not focused on simple poker “games” (“cash poker”) in which Spanish and French players win or lose against one another within the context of the game. It consists of poker games with a “guaranteed prize” (moreover, a very high one), which is tantamount to saying that the form of gambling on which the system rests is that of special, fast “poker tournaments” (of the “Spin & Go” type), in which a substantial pool of participants and wagers can indeed be assembled.
In short, this new international functionality of this game rests on licences to operate poker, and chiefly its “tournament” form, provided for in the Ministerial Order implementing this sub-form of poker, which operators have obtained in order to operate them.
Presuming the “validity” of this arrangement, no objection could be raised to its “legality”.
But… are these genuine “poker tournaments”?
This is the final theoretical obstacle that requires analysis in relation to the legality of the system.
The Spanish Ministerial Order regulating online poker (Order M 3089/2011) clearly distinguishes the two lawful forms: “cash” poker and “tournament poker”.
Not long ago, the DGOJ's authorisation of certain forms of online poker (tournament) offering players exorbitant potential prizes was made public, and we had already analysed the extraordinary and exceptional classification of that game as a “poker tournament” [1] … how could and can a prize of EUR 300,000, for example, be offered when the tournament consisted of 3 players playing 3 successive games, each contributing a maximum entry fee of EUR 50? ….was it a joke? .was it, once again, the miracle of the loaves and fishes?.
These authorisations have been repeated and extended to prizes of EUR 500,000, and then EUR 1,000,000.
This “game” was and is a draw in which EUR 50 is wagered and in which a prize of EUR 300,000 could sometimes be awarded (once awarded, the prize is divided into 3, one of EUR 250,000 and the remaining two of EUR 25,000 each), for 3 winners of the draw, who, indeed, then play for first, second and third prize ……… in a poker game (in fact, in 3 games). In other words, the poker game is almost “the least important part”.
In these cases, ultimately, the promised prize and the “guarantee of payment” do not lie with the players who have participated in that tournament (of whom there are 3, having wagered EUR 150 in total), but with the funds available to the “bank” (which is what the operator becomes in this case), because it is obtained from numerous bettors and a pool of wagers (only in this respect does it resemble a genuine poker tournament). To take matters a step further, the guarantee of payment is not obtained from “prior” wagers or entry fees (or entries in the draw) deposited by customers, but from the mathematics of the software, which fortunately “guarantees” the operator that, statistically, it will never lose what it promises “by way of guarantee”.
Nobody has challenged these authorisations so that a Court may decide whether they are “draws with poker” (unlawful), or “poker” with a draw. For now, therefore, these special authorisations are presumed valid.
So… are these poker activities now offered to Spanish and French players “legal”?
Viewed from this side of the Pyrenees, and until someone challenges anything, the appearance and presumption of legality are evident.
Although the Spanish Gambling Law says nothing about “shared international liquidity”, nobody has challenged (on the grounds of a lack of statutory basis) the Transitional Provision of Royal Decree 1614/2011, the Agreement signed with France, or the DGOJ Resolution of 29 December.
Although we are dealing with a Resolution published in the BOE, but which is not a general Regulation, nobody has challenged it on this ground either.
Although Spanish law does not permit the operation of “draws with poker”, nobody has challenged the resolutions in which the DGOJ exceptionally grants authorisation to offer “poker tournaments with a draw” for various amounts.
Although the Agreement and the Resolution leave the connecting factors for the operation of the games and for taxation in limbo and do not regulate them in any way, this does not appear to be any particular practical impediment to proceeding with these forms of gambling.
In this context, legality is formal, but only “apparent”.
Carlos Lalanda Fernández.
Madrid, 29 January 2018
[1] See my article on these authorisations at www.loyra.com : “Winning EUR 250,000 at poker legally and in pyjamas”