Gaming & Gambling

The latest gambling “fake news”: The Ombudsman’s recommendations

Carlos Lalanda ·

Yet another Report on Gambling to analyse.

And this time from the Ombudsman, whose headline (in the Website Note) is radical and striking:

“The Ombudsman asks the Government to consider a total ban on gambling and betting advertising”.

How does the Ombudsman arrive at this Recommendation?  Is it the only one? What is its significance? What will happen? If we stop at the website headline, which is what most readers do, we will hardly discover what the Report actually says, which is much broader in its subject matter and recommendations.

Even a quick reading might lead to the mistaken conclusion that the Ombudsman is calling for gambling to be banned, when, amongst many other things, he is merely asking THAT THIS BE CONSIDERED AS A POSSIBLE ALTERNATIVE, (HE IS NOT ASKING FOR IT TO BE BANNED), and essentially does so with reference to ONLINE GAMBLING ADVERTISING. There are many other matters set out in the headline and the subsequent introduction, but these receive very secondary attention

In many cases, weary website readers tend to stop at the initial summaries, headlines and introductions, and social media tend to reproduce the truncated, incomplete message, even with a slight bias, ultimately producing what is known as a “fake news story”.

We are therefore interested in turning to the actual text of the Report and reaching a more complete and surprisingly familiar conclusion. This is the (link to the Report ), which still requires clicking another link to access the full text, should anyone wish to complete the task of becoming fully informed.

Reasons for issuing the Report

The sequence of events leading to the issue of the Report began with a complaint: “complaint number: 18018671” (which is not accessible). We do not know whether this is a single complaint or a group of complaints.

The Ombudsman’s Office then took action in December 2018, requesting information from two Ministries involved, the Ministry of Finance (Directorate-General for Gambling and the Ministry of Health, which submitted various preliminary information. In the first case, this was based on the draft (presumably the latest) of the “Decree on Commercial Communications for Gambling Activities and Responsible Gambling”, which has been in the Government’s “oven” for years; and in the second, on the recent National Strategy on Addictions 2017–2024 and the <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Action Plan on Addictions  2018–2020.

Fortunately, we are familiar with both texts and know what they say, since otherwise it would be impossible to discern carefully what the Ombudsman actually “Recommends” in his Report.

As regards the “figures for young problem gamblers”, which appear to have been erroneously taken from the second document cited, it should be recalled that they stem from an unexplained misunderstanding or bias (in other words, an initial “fake news story”), namely a summary PowerPoint page containing an erroneous figure (noted in a more extensive commentary on that study and its methodology (See a commentary on this subject in “Someone Has a Plan”. 4-11-2028)

Various disquisitions in the Report. Tasks it directs.

 Every part of the Report’s substance and recommendations is noteworthy; let us try to dissect it briefly, going a little beyond the “introductions”:

  1. The first Recommendation points to the need to conduct studies on addictive disorders, initiate training in educational and even family settings; promote analysis and the development of prevention and training programmes throughout the chain of stakeholders involved; implement action and prevention protocols, etc.

All this is very well, and has been said in all manner of forums and public assemblies…… What is the difficulty in doing it? The budgetary difficulty, of course. And the idiosyncratic one, in my humble opinion. It would do no harm also to devote a small, widespread effort to enabling individuals and institutions to achieve a degree of maturity in relation to this behavioural shortcoming of ours: “let others decide” …. For the Gambling Levy alone generates more than 1,100 million euros annually in Spain and “waters” most public budgets, for these and other needs. And it is within the power of many Parliaments, Autonomous Community Governments and even local governments to allocate a small part of their budgets to these purposes (rather than refer this task to “others”). Little by little, this first Recommendation is already beginning to be understood and applied.

  1. The next Recommendation concerns the approval of the Decree on Commercial Communications, and we even suspect that it relates to the specific provisions of the draft forwarded by the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling (DGOJ). This recommendation coincides almost exactly with many of the warnings and submissions which, at least to my knowledge, were made at the time and are included in its ministerial file: the lack of specificity as to the enforceability of the rules and prohibitions; invocation of the “general principles of law”, without clearly specifying the conduct constituting offences. The reference to “self-regulation” and its lack of real effectiveness. Many of us, myself included, have endorsed these points in similar terms for years.

This Chapter of the Report does indeed include the recommendation in the “headline”: “To consider, in cooperation with the Autonomous Communities, a total ban on advertising relating to gambling and betting….. except for the lotteries and betting of the State Administration and ONCE,  which may plausibly lead to the adjustment and restriction of the current regime governing online gambling advertising, which is also what many of us have long advocated. Only a few, in a clear minority, seek to maintain its current regulatory position. The “inclination” to distinguish SELAE and ONCE advertising is also an old one.

  1. By contrast, it is very surprising that a “review of existing licences” is also Recommended and referred to. Which licences: online gambling licences, land-based gambling licences (because the Report “takes aim at everyone”, including gambling in establishments and gambling licensed by the Autonomous Communities?? Or the review of the classification of offences: those involving breaches of advertising rules? All of them? Does this not require primary legislation? On this point, the Report is rather cryptic and incomprehensible.
  2. To conclude, the recommendations refer to a totum revolutum of regulatory, preventive and even potentially “expropriatory” actions, alluding to all manner of bodies and institutions, in the manner of a “Big Bang”. A kind of “generalised scolding” or reprimand in which we miss any mention of television or radio networks, or even the football clubs themselves……… which are, ultimately, the ones deriving the material and monetary benefits from this widespread online gambling advertising.

The Report concludes by addressing the two Ministries concerned in the following legal terms:

“Your cooperation is appreciated in advance and, pursuant to Article 30 of the Organic Law on the Ombudsman, you are requested to communicate, as soon as possible, whether or not you accept the Recommendations, indicating, in the latter case, the reasons on which your refusal is based”.

Embarrassment and perplexity

All this causes us a degree of embarrassment and perplexity.

The embarrassment of noticing that the Ombudsman appeared not to “know” anything before. Apparently, nobody had “complained” between 2012, when online gambling advertising campaigns began, and 2018.

And the perplexity because most of the observations on the regulatory shortcomings of the online gambling advertising regime coincide with those of us who have been saying more or less the same thing for almost eight years, since the appearance of the Gambling Law in 2011 and its subsequent implementation in so-called “online gambling”. I refer to the articles and posts published on www.loyra.com concerning this absence of regulations. Thus, the article of 11/05/2015 (\»Gambling Advertising: Nothing Is as It Seems\») or that of 23/05/2016 (\»Gambling Advertising: Five Years without Regulations, and with a Caretaker Government\»);  or a more recent one of 25/11/2018 (\»Harmonise or Temporise\»).

So nothing new on this front.

As for the rest, half and half.

It is right, and it is his mission, to seek to protect rights or address needs which nobody, not even the Public Administrations, is capable of fully addressing in the ordinary course of their work.  This is, by definition, the noble task of the Ombudsman under the Constitution. I recently had occasion to hear a speech by the office-holder, advocating before the Congress of the Spanish Legal Profession the need for intervention by the Public Administrations in the sad situation in which some elderly people in our Spanish society find themselves: they even die alone at home, and this is not discovered until several years later, when a mummified corpse is found. Someone must look after them and take measures. Although the implantation of a GPS tracking CHIP, for example, cannot be imposed on the entire elderly population from a specified age.

In our case, reference is made to problem gamblers and minors addicted to certain games, to treatment in hospitals and to campaigns in educational establishments. Their actual quantification (unknown, as the Report itself acknowledges) must be addressed as a preliminary task, since this is the principal unknown that must be resolved in order to adopt genuinely proportionate measures.

To say that gambling is the cause of problem gambling, as is also stated in the Report, is the same as saying that age is the cause of old age. (But even this does not hold: some medical reports warn of problem gambling arising amongst investors in the “stock market”).

The caretaker State Government, the acting Ombudsman

 We have already said this with regard to the Government in previous analyses. Despite the glaring need to approve Regulations on Online Gambling Advertising since the Gambling Law of 2011 itself, on at least two occasions the draft Decree was consigned to a drawer after all procedural steps had been completed. Because the Government of the day was acting “in a caretaker capacity”. In its technical legal sense (“in a caretaker capacity”), because the Cortes Generales had been convened; or in its ordinary sense (because, in a precarious position, the Government of the day had little confidence that it would remain “alive”). The real reasons for these successive suspensions of the Decree are unknown, at least publicly, and it is already tiresome to recount once again the consequences of its absence: the Law remains “lame” without these Regulations, we have a regime of advertising freedom for online gambling, “self-regulation” is insufficient, there is no real restriction or control, etc.

Let us recall that the Ombudsman also signs his Recommendations in an “acting capacity”, in this case owing to the lack of a basic and simple agreement in a State governed by the rule of law: agreement amongst the political forces to appoint a new one.

How will he secure agreement amongst all the Governments, Assemblies, Departments and Bodies to which he refers directly or implicitly? For the recommendations point in every direction, towards numerous issues of legality, regulation and even constitutional matters, towards various Councils at State and Autonomous Community level, and towards the application of ethical rules.

Many of these institutions, too, currently fall within the category of “institutions acting in a caretaker capacity”.

The direct recipients of the Recommendations, overwhelmed.

 So this is not over; rather, the Report is a new “beginning”:  if anyone has come to think that this was “the end or conclusion” of something, or a genuine “news story”, they must still wait a little. What will happen from now on?

The Recommendations are addressed to the two respective Ministerial Departments mentioned above. They are asked, in this order, to obtain information, undertake a review of the regulation (and communicate this to the Autonomous Communities through the cooperation bodies); undertake a review of licences; in particular, the aforementioned definition of offences and penalties, in other words, a new penalty regime to be proposed to the legislative bodies. And in particular, but without much precision, to publish a Decree on Commercial Communications without further delay, as well as other very specific measures such as reviewing Decree 1614/2011, Autonomous Community regulation (which of them? How?), the regulation of audiovisual communication, etc. At least it is expressly stated that the Directorate-General for the Regulation of Gambling should have the “leading role” in this entire undertaking.

Regulatory and enforcement actions, and analytical and research initiatives, involving a considerable deployment of activities and resources.

Let us hope that these Departments and Ministries do not shelter behind their current “provisional status”, and that they decide to undertake such an immense task.

And that the Ombudsman, once definitively appointed, insists that his recommendations, in their true proportions, are not left in the air.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández.

Madrid, 25 May 2019

 (published in Azarplus magazine)

More publications