Gaming & Gambling

Madrid. Restrictive measures for gaming halls, betting premises and bingo halls. The culmination of a new “Rosonazo”.

Carlos Lalanda ·

Last Thursday, 28-11, “Thanksgiving Day” for the American public, Madrid saw the culmination of the latest in a long series of measures and resolutions adopted by Spain’s Autonomous Communities restricting new authorisations for gambling establishments and premises.

That day, at the time of the traditional “thanksgiving” dinner, the Transparency Portal of the Community of Madrid (CAM) was used to publish the notice of Public Consultation on the Text of the Draft Decree “providing for the suspension of the granting of new marketing authorisations and authorisations for the opening and operation of gambling establishments, pending the planning of such establishments within the territory of the Community of Madrid” (Link to the draft). And a period of 7 days was granted for representations.

But have authorisations already been suspended, or not?

It is not the case that the suspension has already been approved, as appeared to emerge from the press briefing on the meeting of Madrid’s Governing Council on 21-11. For now, there is no definitive suspension and, in addition to the representations procedure, the remaining statutory procedures will now have to follow until the final text is approved, which will enter into force after its publication in the Official Gazette of the Community of Madrid (BOCAM).

However, its initial text already anticipates the effect it will have, retrospectively, from the date of its publication on the CAM Transparency Portal: 28-11-2019 (let us recall: “Thanksgiving Day,” for some). According to the same text, applications submitted to the CAM after that day will not be processed unless evidence is provided that a municipal licence was previously applied for from the relevant Town Council.

Strictly speaking, anyone can submit an application today without meeting this requirement, but there is a strong likelihood that it will subsequently be refused when the Decree is approved. Paradigms of decision-making “technique”.

Content and characteristics of the Decree under consideration

The Decree refers not only to gaming halls and betting premises, but also to “collective games for money and of chance” (that is, bingo halls), which until now could be freely established in Madrid in terms of numbers and location. However, it still does not extend to authorisations to operate gaming machines, which remain the “last bastion” of “freedom of enterprise” (in numerical terms, because these gambling devices are subject to extensive intervention from other administrative perspectives).

The suspension will last for one year from its entry into force, and its effects will extend until a “planning” regulation (on numbers, minimum distances, etc.) is definitively adopted, which the Government undertakes to address within that period. Even on this point, the power to extend this “suspension” by means of an Order is reserved to the Regional Minister of the day, without any specified extension period.

Furthermore, cases in which evidence is provided of the prior submission of a municipal works and/or activity licence to the relevant Town Council are exempted from this suspension, provided that this includes the existence of a Technical Project.

The retrospective scope of the measure.

The new Administration of the Community of Madrid has opted for the approach that safeguards rights, namely processing a General Provision, a Decree, rather than an immediately enforceable Decision, while nevertheless introducing a measure that makes it clearly retrospective and which it seems appropriate to analyse.

The Report accompanying the Draft explains that several measures recently adopted to restrict gambling premises or gaming halls have led to a “surge in the submission of new applications”, even in the Community of Madrid itself while what subsequently became Decree 42/2019 was being processed. In other words, the exact opposite of what the suspension is intended to achieve.

This effect can only be avoided by giving the measure retrospective effect, in this case coinciding with its publication on the Transparency Portal (which is itself published on a website of the Community, that is, as of 28 November). Viewed in this way, it is unlikely that a situation could arise giving rise to compensation for damage, since, as we have noted, cases in which the Municipal Licence application has been submitted to the Town Council are protected where there is also some evidence of the “reality” of the initiative (that is, a “Project” drawn up and submitted in respect of premises).

Having examined the measure intended to be adopted, it is worth reviewing some precedents and outlining a more general view of all those recently adopted.

Precedents and development

The regulatory baroque complexity noted above (a measure not yet approved, but which will take effect from the day its text becomes known) has its rationale in previous experiences of restrictions on gambling authorisations, the study of which could fill a legal monograph or even a doctoral thesis. Its roots lie in the Spanish idiosyncrasy of the “rogue”, which traditionally colours relations between those subject to administrative authority and the Public Administration.

There is an initial similar precedent, back in 1982, in the action of the then Minister of the Interior, J.J. Rosón, in a Spain still without Autonomous Communities, when an initial experience popularly known as the “Rosonazo” of 1982 came to fruition; Royal Decree 895/1982 meant, in practice, that no further authorisations to operate gaming machines could be obtained anywhere in Spain.

Approved without warning on that 30 April, it was not published in the Official State Gazette (BOE) until 8 May, entering into force the following day. This led, in the interval between those dates, to the submission of thousands of additional authorisations to the administrative Registries, a circumstance that subsequently had to be dealt with through numerous court proceedings and procedures of every kind lasting several years.

Once the Autonomous Communities acquired powers in this area, numerous “licence suspensions” followed for gaming machines, but also for the opening of establishments of every kind within their respective territories, gradually adopting the technique of “planning”. However, merely announcing the measure was enough for the number of applications to soar, producing an effect contrary to that intended.

Restrictive regulatory measures have in many cases received the blessing of the Courts, but applications submitted before their entry into force, in our administrative law tradition and because we live under the rule of law, had to be, and must be, respected: “Tempus regit actum”. If you apply for a licence on a given day, before the suspension is in force, it must be granted to you. And if the suspension retrospectively affects applications already submitted, the Public Administration faces grounds for a compensation claim.

The administrative technique of “command and control” that Madrid seeks to avoid.

Over time, the various centres of power (by then at Autonomous Community level) adopted an additional technique to counteract the adverse effects noted above: using their “non-regulatory” decision-making powers, conferred upon them by their respective Government Laws. Under this “technique”, at any Government meeting, even without its having been included on the agenda, it is simply decided “not to grant new authorisations” by means of an individual administrative act. A kind of instruction to its officials which, strictly speaking, is not “general” in nature. It seems to me that this technique is excessive, a clear example of the “individual derogation from a Regulation”, which is the general rule that remains in force for those subject to administrative authority, as against the other measure, and which, for as long as it remains in force, permits applications for and the obtaining of authorisations and licences. These are nothing other than the recognition of individual rights that may only be restricted subject to a series of formal, statutory or regulatory safeguards, which is what distinguishes a State governed by the rule of law.

Without this allocation of powers and framework of formal safeguards, credence would have to be given to the “bulletins” of municipalities, neighbourhoods, associations and residents’ communities throughout Spain, which these days seek, and even “agree upon”, numerous measures suspending gambling authorisations.

Here are the latest measures adopted and published using this peculiar technique (Autonomous Community Resolutions and Decisions contrary to the Regulation in force), in this last month alone:

La Rioja. Resolution 78/2019, of 12 November, of the Technical General Secretariat of the Regional Ministry of Finance, publishing the Decision of the Governing Council of 12 November 2019 on urgent, temporary and transitional planning of authorisations for gaming halls and betting shops in the Autonomous Community of La Rioja (B.O.L.R. No. 136, of 13 November)

Navarra: Decision of the Government of Navarra, of 30 October 2019, suspending the granting of authorisations for the opening of new betting establishments, gaming halls and bingo halls in the Chartered Community of Navarra. (B.O.N. No.216, of 31 October)

Asturias. Decision of 14 November 2019, of the Governing Council, extending the suspension of the granting of authorisations for the opening of new gambling establishments in the Principality of Asturias, pending the determination of the criteria governing the granting of such authorisations. (B.O.P.A No.226, of 22 November)

Anyone who follows and is familiar with these matters knows full well that all these measures are adopted upon the arrival of a particular “wave” or “tsunami” of “anti-gambling” media coverage whose causes and origins are very difficult to identify, and which throws an entire economic sector to the wolves, a wave-like movement from which the Public Administrations can hardly distance themselves without risking being engulfed by the storm themselves.

Before those cited, particularly striking were the actions already undertaken in 2018 by Murcia (Decision of 9 September; and subsequently, in 2019, by the Xunta de Galicia (Resolution of 16 May), by the Government of Extremadura (Decree-Law 1/2019), by the Government of Asturias (Decision of 26 March) or by the Government of Castilla La Mancha (Decision of 21 May). And the list goes on.

Legality of the measures and rules approved in this area.

We have already said that case law generally upholds the validity of planning Decrees where such planning is duly justified.

However, with regard to individual Decisions and Resolutions, we have not identified any line of authority to the same effect, and we have criticised them in certain previous cases, pointing to possible regulatory deficiencies, comments to which I refer:

See the commentary on the “planning” of gaming halls in Castilla La Mancha by this means (or rather, on the revocation of the existing planning) <a href=" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">(Link to the article)

Or on the regulatory inadequacy of the “planning” of Gaming Halls and Betting Premises in Galicia through the Resolution of the Xunta of 16 May (subsequently remedied by Autonomous Community Decree 72/2019. (Link to the article)

Lastly, the paradigmatic case of Extremadura, which did indeed, and without prior notice, approve Decree-Law 1/2019, which was nevertheless subsequently ratified by the Assembly of Extremadura without any amendment. (Link to the article)

There are others, in municipalities such as Barcelona, which are difficult to characterise from a legal perspective, since local authorities lack powers of direct intervention and policing in these matters. (Link to the article)

The Madrid Decree under consideration appears to avoid this approach, and the Madrid Government clearly opts for the Regulatory route, albeit including retrospective effects.

Conclusion: a “Rosonazo” in slow motion in the 21st Century

Thus, with this decision by Madrid, a long list of measures restricting gambling licences culminates and comes to a close for now, just as the “Rosonazo”, which caused so much ink to flow, did in the 20th century. That measure was simple and surgical when it was adopted, now 37 years ago: no further authorisations were to be granted anywhere in Spain. Today, within a framework of complex distribution of powers and competences in this area, various imaginative Government actions follow one another, creating a kind of “Rosonazo in slow motion”.

We shall have time to address the “planning measures” as they emerge.

Madrid, 29 November 2019.

Carlos Lalanda Fernández

Loyra Abogados

More publications