Gaming & Gambling

In March and April, Judgments Galore

Carlos Lalanda ·

In March and April this year, numerous judicial judgments have emerged on matters of various kinds relating to gambling in Spain.

For various reasons, judicial information on this subject is scarce, and the slowness of proceedings of proceedings often means that rulings in disputes have lost their topical relevance.  Furthermore, in tax matters, final decisions were traditionally taken in the lower courts, and no unanimity was reached in the criteria governing those decisions, a situation which has changed with the recent amendment of procedural laws.

The judgments and rulings delivered or reported in recent months are numerous, and we shall mention some of them by way of illustration:

The Judgment of the National High Court of 8 March rules at first instance on the validity of the restriction on distances between gaming halls in the Valencian Community, and declares a provision of Autonomous Community legislation null and void. (See the detailed commentary on this judgment at the following link)

The Judgment of the Supreme Court of 6 March determines how the tax on economic activities (IAE) applies to gaming halls, and the cumulative taxation of the gaming machines installed therein (See the detailed commentary on this judgment. at the following link)

The Resolution of the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal of 15 March confirms that the taxable base for the taxation of random prize draws is calculated on the value of the prizes offered, not those actually paid out.

The Judgment of the Supreme Court of 29 January upholds on appeal in cassation the application of the sanctions regime under Law 13/2011 on Gambling to foreign operators offering online gambling to Spaniards.

The Judgment of the High Court of Justice of Castilla La Mancha of 18 March holds, for the purposes of personal income tax (IRPF), that players' winnings in games of chance may always be offset against losses, and not only from the 2012 tax year, when a legislative amendment to this effect was made.

The Judgment of Administrative Court No. 2 of Palma de Mallorca of 10 April 2018 declares the sanctions regime under the current Gambling Law of the Balearic Islands inapplicable, because it was not submitted to Brussels to fulfil the Public Information requirement, and that this failure to comply with European Directives prevents an entity from being sanctioned under that Law.

All of these, and others, are published and discussed on our website in brief or at length, (in the “Documentation/ judgments and rulings section) or in compiled form, in the  Quarterly Updates on Gambling Legislation.(E.g. the Q1 2018 update, see this link) .helping to provide a better understanding of the disputes being adjudicated and the solutions reached.

In addition to the foregoing, it is worth noting that the recent procedural reform of appeals in cassation will allow new and varied matters to reach the Supreme Court, which will interpret certain issues and take important decisions within a relatively short period. In this category, we can currently mention the following pending matters, announced in several Supreme Court orders granting leave to proceed with certain “appeals of interest for cassation purposes”:

Order of 21-12-2017. On the VAT applicable to the operation of machines in hospitality premises. This appeal (and many other very similar appeals) will determine whether the VAT exemption applicable to the operation of gaming machines extends to the services comprising the economic relationship between the operating company and the proprietors of hospitality establishments where there is alleged “joint operation”. This will resolve the longstanding discrepancy between the decisions of the High Court of Justice (TSJ) of the Valencian Community (which considers the exemption applicable) and the view of other Territorial Chambers, which have hitherto ruled otherwise.

Order of 20-11-2017. On the sale of lotteries over the Internet. This appeal will examine whether the sanctions regime under Law 13/2011 applies to the sale of SELAE lotteries over the Internet where Lottery Agents, who are SELAE sales agents, use the services of external partners for marketing through websites.

Order of 31-10-2017. On the Advertising of online gambling in audiovisual media which in turn produce forms of gambling through those media. This appeal will determine whether these constitute “prohibited self-promotions”, in which case the application of the sanctions regime under the Audiovisual Communication Law will be upheld,

Madrid, 16 May 2018

More publications