Tax & Private Clients
VAT and IPSI in Ceuta and Melilla. Report by the Directorate-General for Taxation
·
On this occasion, the Directorate-General for Taxation issues a Report dated 28-6-2019 (Reference AF 1825-18), at the request of the Tax Services in Ceuta, concerning the liability to VAT or IPSI of various advertising services and other electronic services supplied to online operators with their tax domicile in Ceuta or Melilla.
We have already analysed in previous Notes how the reduction in 2018 of the Gambling Tax burden applicable to online operators that decided to relocate their domicile to those territories had prompted a trend towards optimising the treatment of other taxes applicable to these entities.
In relation to the previous Report on the Binding Tax Ruling of 3-4-2019. we had already analysed the Directorate-General for Taxation's criterion for determining, for the purposes of Gambling Tax and its relationship with Corporation Tax, when a tax domicile in one of these Autonomous Cities becomes effective.
The issue now under consideration focuses on the VAT and IPSI place-of-supply rules for the services received by these operators based there. The services covered by the enquiry and analysed are as follows:
- Advertising services.
- Other electronically supplied services.
Place-of-supply rule and non-liability to VAT.
As regards Value Added Tax, the Report concludes, after analysing the general rules and the exceptions and qualifications in Articles 69,70 and 72 of the VAT Law (LIVA), that advertising and electronically supplied services received by an online gambling operator based in these territories will NOT be subject to VAT, pursuant to Article 69.One.1º of LIVA. This is because they are services whose recipient is a business not established in the territory in which the tax applies. However, this statutory criterion establishes a priori that non-liability does not apply if the services supplied are effectively used or enjoyed in the territory in which the tax applies, as is the case, for example, with operators offering their services to gambling users in Spain.
Nevertheless, the Report favours non-liability, on the decisive ground that the services supplied to the public by the gambling operator are subject to, but exempt from, VAT under Article 20.One.19º of LIVA, as the legislature so decided in order to avoid duplication with taxation under the Gambling Levy. Accordingly, the operator may be regarded as a final consumer of the services it receives, and, if it were unable to deduct input VAT were it chargeable, the principle of tax neutrality would be breached.
IPSI (Tax on Production, Services and Imports) place-of-supply rule in the case of Ceuta
On this second issue, by contrast, the Rule requires the supply of services to be located in Ceuta or Melilla (Article 3 of Law 8/1991), so that advertising and electronically supplied services whose recipient is an online gambling operator established in Ceuta are subject to IPSI, the rate of which is much lower than VAT,
Extrapolation of this administrative doctrine to other cases
In addition to the specific case analysed, a surprising conclusion may be drawn from the Report's invocation of EU law and from the consequences of the interpretation of Article 20.One.19º of LIVA (exemption for games of chance services, and limits of the exemption)
The exemption for the supply of games of chance services to the public does not extend, under the second paragraph of this Article, to other services such as management services received by operating companies, and those companies cannot deduct the input VAT on the invoices received, a circumstance which breaches tax neutrality, as they bear the VAT burden as if they were final consumers.
This effect is technically counteracted in the case of intra-Community transactions. This is because a \»reverse charge\» applies in such cases. This applies both to land-based gambling companies and to online gambling companies. However, this does not happen in domestic transactions, with services received by gambling operators whose origin and destination are in Spain being subject to VAT, which those operators are obliged to bear because that clause remains in the provisions. This is what a recent judgment of the Supreme Court dated 12-3-2019 has served to recall, delivered in relation to the services \»supplied\» by the proprietors of hospitality establishments to gaming machine operators when they install automatic machines in their establishments.
The argument contained in the Binding Tax Ruling, although not directly applicable, once again places us in a position to invoke a broader interpretation of the exemption for the transactions referred to in the second paragraph of that Article 20.One.19 of LIVA, in the light of the Community legal order, which revolves around the aforementioned principle of neutrality. A working hypothesis to which we already referred in our critique of that judgment.
Madrid, 1 July 2019
Tax Department of Loyra Abogados